Seemor

New York › The Bronx › City Island

Best Restaurants in City Island

4 restaurants analyzed · New York

City Island feels like a New England fishing village that happens to be reachable by bridge from Pelham Bay, and the restaurants lean into it with seafood shacks and dockside dining rooms up and down City Island Avenue. Prices trend higher here than the Bronx average, reflecting the fresh catch and water views. It's the go-to spot in the borough for a proper lobster or clam dinner.

Restaurants

• ATIK Restaurant B+ · Mediterranean restaurant, Seafood restaurant
• City Island Lobster House B+ · Seafood restaurant, Steakhouse
• Vistamar Restaurant & Lounge B+ · Latin American restaurant, Seafood restaurant
• Johnny's Reef B · Seafood restaurant, Fast food restaurant

Top Cuisines

• Seafood — 2 restaurants
• American — 2 restaurants

Find Your Next Meal in City Island

• Casual Meal restaurants in City Island — Quick, quality, no fuss
• Date Night restaurants in City Island — Romantic dining for two
• Fun with Friends restaurants in City Island — Something everyone will enjoy
• Family Outing restaurants in City Island — Kid-friendly, stress-free dining
• Solo Dining restaurants in City Island — Comfortable spots for dining alone
• Business Discussion restaurants in City Island — Professional setting, no distractions
• Vegetarian-Friendly restaurants in City Island
• Vegan-Friendly restaurants in City Island
• Gluten-Free Friendly restaurants in City Island
• Walk-ins Welcome restaurants in City Island
• Highly Authentic restaurants in City Island
• Local Favorites restaurants in City Island
• Easy Parking restaurants in City Island
• Amazing Setting restaurants in City Island
• Hidden Gems restaurants in City Island
• Great Value restaurants in City Island

Explore City Island on Seemor →