Exeter brings together classic Italian cooking, local pizza traditions, and American comfort food at approachable prices. Generous portions, pan-fried Sicilian pies, barbecue sides and sauces, and polished Italian meals give the area a strong reason to linger over familiar favorites. Exeter is a rewarding stop for satisfying, well-made comfort food with a distinctly local feel.
Preliminary reads are early assessments from a smaller review sample, not full Seemor analyses.
This old-school, family-run pizza stop draws devoted locals for its unusual pepperoni pie, wings, and extensive beer selection. The food can be excellent, but recent accounts also describe dry or overcooked items and frustrating service lapses. Try: Pepperoni pizza.
This is a comfortable, American-themed barbecue diner with friendly table service, generous seating, and an easygoing local feel. The best bets appear to be the sauces, collard greens, ribs, burgers, and desserts, while brisket and delivery orders have produced some notable misses. Try: collard greens.
This is a cozy, family-style local pizzeria built around crisp-edged pan-fried Sicilian pizza and notably strong wings. Most diners find the food memorable and fairly priced, though grease, undercooking, delays, and uneven service appear in the critical reports. Try: Pan-fried Sicilian pizza.