Seemor
The Fourth Man in the Fire PizzeriaBWorth Trying
832 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1V3, Canada
· Pizza restaurant, Dessert restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (1869 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Well-loved pizza-and-donuts spot with generous portions and lively vibe; great dine-in slices and famous donuts, but delivery delays, occasional dine-in restrictions, and value concerns can frustrate.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
The Fourth Man in the Fire delivers solid neighborhood pizzeria quality with fresh sauce and crisp crust that earn frequent praise, complemented by warm, friendly staff. However, inconsistent execution—particularly delivery delays and occasional quality dips—prevents higher grades, and premium slice pricing limits value perception. Best experienced dining in for hot, reliable pizza and fresh donuts.
Restaurant Summary
This West End slice-and-donut hangout feels warm and bustling, with a no-fuss, old-school diner energy. Staff are often described as friendly and considerate—one guest even noted a heads up about active parking enforcement. Another put it simply: "The sauce tastes fresh and the crust stays crisp." The cooking leans classic American-Italian: crisp-edged pies, generous toppings, and Brooklyn-style squares. The best experiences come dining in or grabbing slices hot; delivery can run late and arrive cool. Donuts are a draw—apple fritters and sour cream glazed get raves—though a few guests found them less fresh later in the day. If you like straightforward, well-executed pies and a big, sweet finish, this place is easy to like. Families are well served here. Kids gravitate to plain cheese or pepperoni, mozzarella sticks, and garlic breadsticks, and capping the meal with donuts rarely misses. There is no dedicated kids menu, but the pizza-first lineup and simple sides make it kid friendly by nature. Allergies received attentive handling in recent visits; for delivery, consider dine-in instead for the most reliable experience.
At a Glance
- Fresh, flavorful sauce and crisp crust win frequent praise
- Donuts are a destination item when fresh
- Delivery frequently delayed and arrives cool
- Inconsistent dine-in seating policy frustrates slice buyers
- Premium pricing for slices and whole pies
What Sets It Apart
- house_donut_operation
- brooklyn_square_pies
- slice_and_dine_hybrid
What People Love
- Bright, tomato-forward sauce that tastes fresh
- Generous portions and hearty Brooklyn squares
- Friendly staff and small community gestures
- Donuts that many call best in the city
Points of Concern
- Delivery orders show long prep times and arrive cold for some diners
- Occasional dine-in restrictions for slice purchases despite open tables
- Pricing feels steep for slices and desserts to value-sensitive guests
- Donut freshness and labeling vary later in the day
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleHybrid
Average CostC$38-58 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Split a mid-priced pizza (C$34–36) and a side (C$11–12) for good value.
- Add a Caprese salad (C$16.99) to balance heavier pies.
- Choose specific donuts at the counter rather than assortments when possible.
Perfect For
- Casual pizza night with a donut finale
- Pre-show slices on Dundas West
- Families seeking easy kid-pleasers
- Solo slice-and-go lunches
Location Insights
Area: Trendy West End strip mixing indie eateries, bakeries, and bars; draws locals and destination diners.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked; typical urban street parking enforcement noted by patrons.
Nearby: Near Trinity Bellwoods and Dundas-Ossington restaurants; good bar hopping and dessert options nearby.
West Queen WestWest Queen West is a trendy and artistic neighborhood with a lively dining scene featuring eclectic cafes, boutique restaurants, and bars. The area is known for its creative energy, attracting a hip crowd interested in contemporary art, music, and innovative cuisine.
Dundas WestDundas West is a micro-neighborhood within West Queen West characterized by a mix of independent eateries, casual dining spots, and a growing number of artisanal food shops. It has a laid-back yet vibrant atmosphere popular with locals seeking diverse and affordable dining options.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–21:30
Tuesday11:00–21:30
Wednesday11:00–21:30
Thursday11:00–21:30
Friday11:00–22:30
Saturday11:00–22:30
Sunday11:00–21:30
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →