Reservations · Delivery · Outdoor seating
Fixed-menu steak frites with seconds and lively vibes; great value for many, but chronic reservation delays and cramped seating can sour the night.
Medium Rare delivers solid neighborhood steakhouse quality anchored by strong food quality—tender steak, crispy fries, and a beloved secret sauce—at exceptional value for the price point. However, inconsistent execution (underseasoned steak, soggy fries, brunch variability) and operational challenges like chronic reservation delays and tight seating prevent grade A territory. Friendly service and a warm, bustling atmosphere make it worth visiting for casual steak frites and brunch groups, but reliability concerns keep it from competing with the area's premier dining destinations.
The scene is warm and bustling, with servers hustling plates of steak frites while the bar shakes espresso martinis. One diner summed it up: "Two rounds of steak and fries at this price felt like a throwback deal." Energy runs high and the room can feel a bit cramped, especially around the host stand where waits often spill past reservation times. The cooking leans classic and comforting: a one-choice culotte steak, crisp fries, fresh bread, salad, and that secret sauce people rave about. When the kitchen is clicking, steak temps land right and the second helping seals the value; on off nights, fries can droop and pacing drags between rounds. Brunch brings bottomless drinks and party vibes, great for groups who want easy choices over long menus. For families, the straightforward setup—bread, salad, steak, and fries—works for many kids, and dessert slices are huge to share. There is a portobello option for non-meat eaters, but feedback is mixed, so parents of picky eaters may prefer to stick with steak and fries. No kids menu was mentioned, so plan portions accordingly.
Area: Lively Midtown East/Murray Hill corridor popular with young professionals and after-work crowds.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked streets with steady footfall into late evening.
Nearby: Bars, casual restaurants, residential towers, and commuter flow to Grand Central nearby.
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →