Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Classic, thick-crust Italian-American pies with generous toppings and big portions; great for families and takeout, but dine-in hours, phone holds, and counter service reliability can frustrate.
Petrillo's Pizza earns its grade through strong food quality and exceptional local loyalty that spans generations, but inconsistent execution and stretched service capacity prevent higher standing. The thick, topping-heavy pies and generous portions deliver solid value for families, though phone waits and occasional quality lapses—undercooked dough, burnt edges—create friction that keeps this classic SGV institution competitive with, rather than ahead of, the area's better neighborhood pizzerias.
The room feels lively and old-school, a classic SGV hangout where families crowd the booths and regulars swap stories while pies hit the tables. One diner said the pizza was "stacked and best hot," and takeout lines hum on busy nights. Expect friendly-but-stretched counter service and occasional waits when the phone lines light up. The cooking leans classic Italian-American: thick, fluffy crusts, generous toppings, and saucy pastas. It is comfort-first, not flashy, and shines when the Petrillo Special or pepperoni-and-sausage lands fresh from the oven. Portions are big enough to share, with value strongest on the large square-cut pies and Tuesday deals; pastas satisfy, though a few guests wished for more sauce. For families, this is an easy win: kids gravitate to pepperoni pizza and buttered pasta, while vegetarians can stick to cheese or bianca pies, salads, and minestrone. There is no clear vegan mains beyond salad, and the dine-in schedule can be quirky, so call ahead before promising pizza night at a table.
Area: Suburban SGV corridor with heavy foot and car traffic, family groups and long-time locals frequenting legacy eateries.
Safety: Generally safe with steady foot traffic; occasional evening crowding around takeout entrance.
Nearby: Near other SGV dining, Huntington Library within a short drive; mixed retail and services along Valley Blvd.
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →