Seemor

CrumblC+

423 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10301 · Cookie shop, Dessert shop · West Brighton

Fun cookie stop with rotating flavors and big portions, but expect occasional service hiccups, delivery delays, and inconsistency on toppings and doneness.

Our take

Crumbl delivers strong food quality with creative rotating flavors and generous portions that keep regulars returning, but quality variance—underbaked centers, light toppings, and occasional missed items—prevents higher marks. Extended waits and delivery delays during peak times, paired with reported hygiene concerns, further limit the grade. As a casual dessert stop with exciting flavors and shareable portions, it's worth a visit for cookie enthusiasts willing to accept occasional inconsistencies.

One caveat: Delivery via app or third-parties can be very slow or canceled, with refunds delayed

Standout dishes

What people love

Opening Hours

Monday08:00–22:00 Tuesday08:00–22:00 Wednesday08:00–22:00 Thursday08:00–22:00 Friday08:00–00:00 Saturday08:00–00:00 Sunday
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →