Outdoor seating
A lively, stylish American brunch spot in Marylebone with standout pancakes, generous portions, and a bustling vibe—great for groups and brunch lovers, but service and value can be hit-or-miss.
Sunday in Brooklyn delivers solid A-grade performance through strong food quality anchored by signature pancakes and creative American comfort fare, paired with exceptional setting appeal in a vibrant Marylebone location. However, inconsistent execution and variable service attentiveness during peak periods prevent grade A territory, while higher pricing relative to perceived value tempers overall appeal for cost-conscious diners.
Sunday in Brooklyn brings a slice of New York's brunch culture to the heart of Marylebone, offering generous portions, a lively atmosphere, and a menu that puts creative spins on American classics. The vibe is energetic and stylish, with both indoor and alfresco seating that makes it a popular destination for groups, families, and anyone seeking a vibrant brunch scene. The signature pancakes are a divisive highlight—some call them 'heavenly,' others find them too rich or cake-like, but they're undeniably a talking point. Culinarily, the restaurant leans into modern American comfort food with inventive touches—think fried chicken sandwiches, miso leeks, and playful desserts. The menu is approachable for most, but those seeking traditional British brunch or lighter fare may find the offerings a bit heavy. Service is a mixed bag: while many guests praise friendly staff and quick seating, others report inattentiveness or slow response, especially during busy periods. Value perceptions vary, with some diners feeling the prices are justified by portion size and location, while others balk at the bill for what they receive. For families, Sunday in Brooklyn is generally a safe bet. The menu includes kid-friendly options like pancakes, egg sandwiches, and granola, and several reviews mention positive experiences with children. However, the bustling, sometimes noisy environment and the occasional long wait may not suit every family. If your kids are adventurous eaters or love sweet treats, they'll likely be happy here—but picky eaters or those sensitive to noise might struggle. Menu data confirms the presence of vegetarian options and lighter starts, but vegan and allergy-friendly choices are limited.
Area: Trendy, bustling central London neighborhood with a mix of upscale boutiques, offices, and residential streets. Popular with young professionals, families, and tourists.
Safety: Generally very safe, well-lit, and busy throughout the day. High foot traffic and well-maintained public spaces.
Nearby: Located near Oxford Street shopping, close to Bond Street station, surrounded by other cafes, restaurants, and retail outlets.
Available: Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →