Seemor
Fishers In The CityA-Worth Trying
58 Thistle St, Edinburgh EH2 1EN
· Seafood restaurant, Fish and seafood restaurant
· 4.6/5 Google (1739 reviews)
Reservations
Excellent modern Scottish seafood with lively service and standout linguine and halibut; book ahead and expect premium pricing with occasional service variability.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
Fishers In The City delivers exceptional seafood quality with creative contemporary technique and warm, knowledgeable service that elevates the dining experience. Occasional kitchen inconsistencies and space constraints during peak service prevent grade A territory, though the charming Thistle Street location and strong loyalty metrics confirm its standing as a respected Edinburgh seafood destination.
Restaurant Summary
Set just off George Street, Fishers In The City feels lively and polished without tipping into stuffy. Much of the praise centers on warm, personable servers who make the evening flow, with lines like, "Our waiter talked us through oysters and fixed the perfect wine." Still, a few guests describe brusque door management during peak times, so reservations help preserve the otherwise easygoing mood. The culinary approach leans contemporary Scottish seafood with creative touches: think halibut with saffron beurre blanc, scallops with caramelised cauliflower, and linguine enriched by brown crab butter rather than pub-classic monotony. It suits diners who enjoy refined flavors more than simple fry-house fare, though fish and chips here can still shine when the kitchen is on form. Expect premium ingredients and tidy plating over theatrics; most guests call it a must for seafood in the city. Families do fine if kids like straightforward bites such as fish and chips, chips, or a simple salad, but there is no clear kids menu on the current list. Picky eaters may find the seafood-forward lineup limiting; if you need guaranteed kid favorites, consider booking at a quieter hour and confirm options like plain fish or sides to keep things stress-free.
At a Glance
- Fresh, precisely cooked Scottish seafood with creative accents
- Friendly, knowledgeable servers who guide wine and oyster choices
- Door service can be curt at peak times; reservations advised
- Occasional misses on fish and chips texture or scallop temperature
- Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food
What Sets It Apart
- central_new_town_location
- contemporary_scottish_seafood
- notable_pasta_seafood_dishes
What People Love
- That first taste of ultra-fresh halibut or scallops
- Servers who make ordering feel easy and fun
- Seafood linguine with rich crab butter depth
- Central location tucked onto a charming side street
Points of Concern
- A minority report brusque or dismissive host interactions at busy times
- Isolated complaints about greasy fish and chips or lukewarm scallops
- Peanut/nut anaphylaxis accommodation questioned by one diner; shared-kitchen risk
- Creative/fusion lean may not suit conservative palates or picky eaters
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost£52-70 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- For a balanced meal: scallops (£13) + halibut (£33.50) + a side of hasselback (£4.50).
- Value route: madras coley and king prawn curry (£22) plus mixed salad (£4).
- Shellfish fans: linguine with half lobster (£50) if you want a deluxe upgrade.
Perfect For
- Seafood-focused date night near George Street
- Business lunch with polished but relaxed vibe
- Visitors seeking a refined take on Scottish catch
- Locals celebrating with premium shellfish
Location Insights
Area: Central New Town side street with boutique shops and offices; caters to business diners, tourists, and locals seeking quality seafood.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, and busy in evenings with steady foot traffic.
Nearby: Steps from George Street bars and shopping; short walk to Princes Street and city sights.
New TownThe dining scene in New Town is diverse, featuring a range of upscale restaurants, trendy cafes, and traditional Scottish pubs. The atmosphere is lively yet refined, attracting both locals and visitors seeking quality dining experiences in a stylish setting.
West EndThe West End within New Town is known for its artistic vibe, independent shops, and a slightly more relaxed dining atmosphere with a focus on contemporary and international cuisine.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday12:00–22:00
Tuesday12:00–22:00
Wednesday12:00–22:00
Thursday12:00–22:00
Friday12:00–22:00
Saturday12:00–22:00
Sunday12:00–22:00
Available: Reservations
View full analysis on Seemor →