Seemor
Cello's PizzeriaB+Worth Trying
36 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10003
· Pizza restaurant
· 4.8/5 Google (812 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Outstanding East Village slice shop with crisp NY-style pies, a beloved vodka slice, quick counter service, and budget-friendly prices, though occasional burnt bottoms and delivery issues appear.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Cello's Pizzeria delivers solid neighborhood slice shop quality anchored by exceptional food quality—the vodka slice and pepperoni-jalapeno standouts showcase crisp, balanced execution that justifies its East Village reputation. However, inconsistent execution with occasional burnt bottoms and cold delivery prevents a higher grade, while strong location appeal and excellent value make it competitive with respected local favorites rather than a destination establishment.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels warm and bustling, a classic St. Marks slice shop energy where lines move and pies glisten under the lamps. Staff are often friendly and quick, with one diner noting the team turned around a fresh slice in minutes. However, expect occasional burnt bottoms and delivery hiccups based on a minority of reports. The cooking leans elevated NY slice with focused toppings—think creamy vodka sauce, jalapeno-pepperoni heat, and creamy burrata. The culinary approach is classic with small twists: crisp, thin, and balanced rather than chefy theatrics. If you like a slice that holds flat with no flop, this is your style. Families do fine here: plain and margherita work for kids, though some specialty slices run spicy for younger palates. One parent praised the owner for swapping a too-spicy pie, a reassuring touch. Seating is better than many slice spots, but at peak times expect limited space and quick turnover.
At a Glance
- Vodka slice is a consistent standout with crisp, no-flop base
- Excellent value for East Village; $4-$6 slices
- Occasional burnt bottoms and over-reheating noted
- Delivery delays and cold pies reported by a minority
- Peak times bring lines and limited seating
What Sets It Apart
- standout_vodka_slice
- crisp_no_flop_style
- more_seating_than_typical_slice_shops
What People Love
- Crisp, airy crust with no flop
- Balanced, tangy vodka sauce
- Pepperoni cups with jalapeno heat
- More seating than most slice shops
- Friendly, fast counter service
Points of Concern
- Burnt bottoms or over-reheat appear periodically, especially at busy times
- Delivery can be slow or arrive cool on bad nights
- Service tone varies; a few reports of brusque interactions
- Review patterns show hype-driven traffic; expectations should be set for a slice shop format
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$12-$18 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Start with a vodka slice, add a plain or pepperoni for balance
- If trying burrata, request a fresh reheat and confirm cheese temperature preference
Perfect For
- Quick pre-bar bite on St. Marks
- Casual pizza crawl with friends
- Solo lunch with a crisp slice
- Budget-friendly, high-quality snack
Location Insights
Area: Lively, youth-driven block with bars and late-night eats; heavy foot traffic and casual vibe.
Safety: Generally safe, busy at night; typical urban crowds and occasional rowdiness.
Nearby: Near St. Marks nightlife, cafes, and shops; close to subway lines on 2nd Ave and Astor Pl.
East VillageThe East Village offers a dynamic dining scene with a mix of casual eateries, trendy restaurants, and ethnic cuisine reflecting its diverse community. The social atmosphere is lively and creative, attracting a crowd interested in arts, music, and nightlife, with a generally safe and accessible environment.
St. Marks PlaceSt. Marks Place is a well-known micro-neighborhood within the East Village famous for its bohemian vibe, casual dining spots, bars, and late-night venues. It is a hub for socializing and entertainment, often bustling with energy and a youthful crowd.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday12:00–22:00
Tuesday12:00–22:00
Wednesday12:00–22:00
Thursday12:00–00:00
Friday12:00–00:00
Saturday12:00–00:00
Sunday12:00–22:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →