Seemor
Brooklyn Pizza CrewB-Worth Trying
758 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216
· Pizza restaurant, Delivery Restaurant, Restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (590 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Neighborhood slice shop with standout specialty slices and vegan/GF flexibility, but inconsistent execution and delivery issues mean the best experiences are in person.
Why it gets a B- for overall quality
Brooklyn Pizza Crew delivers solid neighborhood pizza with moments of excellence—the food quality reaches impressive heights when execution clicks, earning praise for crispy crusts and well-balanced toppings. However, inconsistent execution and recent quality concerns including burnt and stale pies prevent a higher grade. Best experienced as a quick counter stop rather than delivery order, this slice shop satisfies casual cravings but lacks the reliability expected of grade A establishments.
Restaurant Summary
This Crown Heights slice shop feels casual and neighborhoody, with a couple of picnic tables and a steady stream of walk-ins. On a good day, slices land hot and crisp—one regular said the crust was "perfect, nice and crunchy," while another praised the cup-and-char pepperoni. However, expect variability; some diners reported burnt or stale deliveries and curt phone interactions during busy stretches. Cooking is classic New York pizza with a few twists—think Grandma and Bianco slices alongside standards. The approach leans familiar rather than flashy: when the undercarriage is browned and the balance of sauce and cheese clicks, it satisfies that borough-slice craving. Delivery can dilute quality, so the best bet is grabbing slices fresh at the counter. Families do fine here: it is a quick-stop spot with kid-pleasing classics. Picky eaters can stick to plain or pepperoni, while those with restrictions will appreciate vegan cheese and meats plus a gluten-free option. Seating is scarce, so plan on a fast casual pit stop or take it to go.
At a Glance
- Classic NY slices with crowd-pleasers like Grandma and Bianco
- Strong vegan and gluten-free options welcomed by locals
- Inconsistent execution (burnt, undercooked, or stale pies reported)
- Delivery quality control and zone limits frustrate some customers
- Fast counter service and good for solo quick bites
What Sets It Apart
- robust_vegan_and_gf_pizza_options
- neighborhood_slice_vibe_with_art_mural
What People Love
- Crunchy crust when fresh
- Balanced sauce and quality pepperoni
- Vegan cheese and meats available
- Bianco slice creaminess
Points of Concern
- Quality swings: reports of burnt, undercooked, or stale pies, especially via delivery
- Delivery issues: zone refusals and third-party mishandling frustrate customers
- Service tone varies: some helpful fixes, some curt phone responses
- Review patterns show isolated safety complaint and portion-size frustration for GF Grandma
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleHybrid
Average Cost$16-24 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Based on reviews, try Bianco or Grandma in-store; choose vegan pepperoni for plant-based; confirm GF size and pricing before ordering
Perfect For
- A quick neighborhood slice run
- Mixed-diet groups needing vegan or GF pizza
- Solo lunch between errands
- Casual weeknight takeout
Location Insights
Area: Lively Crown Heights corridor with steady foot traffic, mix of longtime residents and newer transplants.
Safety: Generally safe with active street life; typical urban awareness recommended at night.
Nearby: Near cafes, bars, and small shops along Nostrand Ave; close to residential blocks and bus routes.
Bedford-StuyvesantBedford-Stuyvesant offers a dynamic dining scene that ranges from traditional soul food and Caribbean eateries to trendy cafes and innovative restaurants. The social atmosphere is lively and community-oriented, with a growing influx of new residents contributing to a blend of old and new cultural influences.
Stuyvesant HeightsStuyvesant Heights is known for its well-preserved historic architecture and a more tranquil, residential vibe compared to the busier commercial corridors. Dining here tends to be more neighborhood-focused with a few standout local spots.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:30–23:00
Tuesday11:30–23:00
Wednesday11:30–23:00
Thursday11:30–00:00
Friday11:30–01:00
Saturday11:30–01:00
Sunday11:30–23:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →