Seemor
Alligator LoungeC+Worth Trying
600 Metropolitan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211
· Bar, Pizza restaurant, Sports bar
· 4.4/5 Google (1535 reviews)
Takeout · Outdoor seating
Lively Williamsburg dive-bar staple with cheap drinks and a free personal cheese pizza per drink; great for groups and karaoke, but inconsistent service and occasional safety and inclusivity concerns.
Why it gets a C+ for overall quality
Alligator Lounge delivers reliable fun and exceptional value through its free personal pizza deal and lively karaoke atmosphere, making it a solid neighborhood hangout. However, inconsistent service quality and crowding during peak hours prevent a higher grade. Best suited for groups seeking a casual, high-energy bar experience rather than refined dining or quiet conversation.
Restaurant Summary
The scene skews warm and bustling with karaoke in the back and cheap rounds up front, where bartenders hustle and a pizza oven glows. As one guest put it, "Beer in hand and a hot personal pie felt like instant comfort." Expect a true dive-bar hang that can get packed and rowdy on peak nights. The cooking is straightforward bar fare: a simple cheese pizza cooked to order with optional toppings, included with each drink. Drinks run inexpensive for the neighborhood, and the pizza deal anchors the value. This suits groups, birthday hangs, and anyone who loves a high-energy, games-and-karaoke night more than curated cocktails or culinary finesse. Families should look elsewhere. Despite the pizza, this is a late-night bar environment with crowds, noise, and alcohol-focused service. No kids menu, and the vibe leans adult; bring teens at most during earlier, quieter hours if at all.
At a Glance
- Free personal pizza with every drink is a standout value
- Lively karaoke and games make it a fun group spot
- Crowding and long pizza lines during peak hours
- Repeated complaints about rude staff and policy confusion
- Isolated but serious reports of harassment and discriminatory behavior
What Sets It Apart
- free_pizza_with_each_drink
- karaoke_back_room
- games_pool_skee_ball
What People Love
- The thrill of getting a hot pizza with every round
- Cheap cocktails and beer-shot combos
- Supportive karaoke crowd on good nights
- Divey Williamsburg vibe close to the train
Points of Concern
- Crowded walkways and tight space by pool tables can feel unsafe during rush
- Inconsistent service attitude from staff and pizza station noted by multiple guests
- Confusion over pizza ticket rules (per drink vs per person) frustrates patrons
- Review patterns show signs of polarized experiences; weigh strong positives against detailed negative incidents
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$18-$30 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Lean on value cocktails ($8-$12) paired with the included cheese pizza
- Add a single topping to personalize the pie without slowing the line too much
Perfect For
- Budget-friendly group hang
- Pre-game before a show
- Casual birthday night with karaoke
- Late-night neighborhood crawl
Location Insights
Area: Trendy Williamsburg strip near L/G trains; youthful nightlife, games, and karaoke crowd.
Safety: Generally busy and well-trafficked; late-night crowding can feel chaotic; isolated complaints about harassment.
Nearby: Bars, restaurants, and venues nearby; convenient post-dinner stop; residential side streets around.
WilliamsburgWilliamsburg offers a dynamic dining environment with a mix of casual bars, innovative restaurants, and eclectic eateries. The social atmosphere is lively and youthful, with many venues catering to a crowd interested in craft cocktails, live music, and artisanal food.
East WilliamsburgEast Williamsburg retains some of its industrial roots with warehouses and creative spaces, offering a slightly more laid-back and authentic Brooklyn experience. The dining scene here includes hip bars and lounges that attract a crowd looking for a relaxed yet trendy atmosphere.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday15:00–04:00
Tuesday15:00–04:00
Wednesday15:00–04:00
Thursday15:00–04:00
Friday15:00–04:00
Saturday13:00–04:00
Sunday13:00–04:00
Available: Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →