Seemor
Olde City Cheesesteaks & BrewBWorth Trying
66 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016
· Sports bar, Bar, Cheesesteak restaurant
· 4.6/5 Google (426 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Lively Philly-leaning sports bar with solid bar snacks and customizable cheesesteaks, good beer deals, but inconsistent service and delivery hiccups; best enjoyed in-house during games.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Olde City Cheesesteaks delivers reliable neighborhood appeal with solid food quality and strong game-day community energy, but inconsistent execution between dine-in and delivery prevents a higher grade. The sports-bar atmosphere and fair value make it a dependable choice for casual dining and watching games, though it falls short of the area's premier dining destinations.
Restaurant Summary
Game days here feel rowdy and welcoming, with TVs on every wall and green jerseys everywhere. Guests describe bartenders as fast and friendly when the room is humming, though some note music can skew loud. One diner summed it up: "Perfect spot to catch the game, beer cold and food out quick." The cooking leans classic bar comfort over bells and whistles: big cheesesteaks with your pick of cheese, craveable fries, wings, and a solid burger. It shines most when eaten in-house; several delivery orders mention missing sauces or soggy bread. If you want a faithful Philly replica, opinions vary—think tasty, customizable, and filling more than purist perfection. For families, it is fairly kid-friendly. Burgers, tenders, and plain fries are easy wins, and portions are shareable. There is no kids menu called out, but the straightforward options suit younger eaters. Expect sports crowd energy during games and plan earlier visits for a calmer meal.
At a Glance
- High-energy Eagles/Penn State watch bar with strong community vibe
- Good lunch specials and happy hour value for Midtown
- Delivery and phone coordination issues reported
- Music and crowd noise can be loud during peak times
- Bread can get soggy when wrapped; dine-in preferred
What Sets It Apart
- Philly team watch hub
- House-baked pretzels
- Customizable cheesesteaks with Cooper Sharp and Whiz
What People Love
- Community feel for Philly fans
- Large, customizable cheesesteaks
- Crispy, seasoned fries and bar snacks
- Staff switching TVs to requested games
- Value-friendly lunch deals
Points of Concern
- Delivery reliability and missing items (sauces/cheese) mentioned by multiple guests
- Communication about hours and phones can be inconsistent late night
- Service can lag for large groups; billing delays reported
- Noise levels high during games; music sometimes too loud
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$36-48 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Choose dine-in for cheesesteaks to preserve bread texture
- Try lunch combo when available for value
- Customize cheese (Cooper Sharp or Whiz) and consider add-ons like mushrooms or cherry pepper spread
Perfect For
- Watching a big game with friends
- Casual after-work bites and beers
- Hearty lunch special near Madison Square Park
- Group meetups for Philly sports fans
Location Insights
Area: Busy Midtown South corridor serving office crowds and hotel guests; game-day destination for Philly fans.
Safety: Well-trafficked commercial blocks; generally safe with typical late-night urban considerations.
Nearby: Near Madison Square Park, NoMad hotels, offices, and transit; heavy foot traffic on game nights.
Murray HillMurray Hill offers a vibrant dining scene with a mix of casual eateries, trendy bars, and upscale restaurants catering primarily to working professionals and residents. The area is lively during weekdays with a steady flow of office workers and becomes more relaxed in the evenings and weekends.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–01:00
Tuesday11:00–01:00
Wednesday11:00–01:00
Thursday11:00–02:00
Friday11:00–02:00
Saturday11:00–02:00
Sunday11:00–01:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →