Seemor
Tony + Benny'sB-Worth Trying
LaGuardia Airport, Headhouse Food Hall Terminal B, Queens, NY 11371
· Pizza restaurant, Italian restaurant, Pasta shop
· 4.6/5 Google (556 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Solid airport pizza with quick service and friendly staff, but quality and service can be inconsistent and add-on charges may surprise.
Why it gets a B- for overall quality
Tony + Benny's delivers solid airport dining through reliable pizza quality and quick, friendly counter service, but inconsistent execution on pasta and occasional underbaked items and isolated food safety concerns prevent a higher grade. For travelers seeking fast, affordable slices in Terminal B, it's a dependable choice—stick to the pizza and skip the pasta.
Restaurant Summary
Inside Terminal B’s food hall, Tony + Benny’s feels busy and upbeat: slices fly from the oven, staff call out orders, and travelers grab seats in the shared area. One traveler said, "They had my slice hot in minutes," capturing the quick, friendly service vibe. Expect occasional lines and a lively food hall hum. The cooking leans classic New York: cheese and specialty slices, stromboli, chicken parm, simple pasta. At its best, the pizza has a well-balanced crust with flavorful toppings, and the big garlic knots satisfy. Weak spots show up in pasta and occasional underbaked stromboli, so stick to freshly reheated slices for the safest win. For families, this is a kid-friendly stop thanks to cheese and pepperoni slices, garlic rolls ($5.95), and basic pasta. Salads and veggie sides exist, but reviews mention mixed freshness; choose visible, fresh-looking items. No kids menu, but portions are shareable and easy for picky eaters.
At a Glance
- Fast, friendly counter service with frequent staff shout-outs
- Good airport value, especially combo meals with drink
- Inconsistent quality on pasta and occasional underbaked stromboli
- Pricing confusion on add-ons and reported 3% surcharge
- Isolated food safety issues (salad bug, slice touching sneeze guard glass)
What Sets It Apart
- airport_combo_value
- consistent_hot_slice_reheat
- friendly_named_staff
What People Love
- Hot slices in minutes
- Warm, personable staff
- Tasty BBQ chicken slice
- Large garlic knots
Points of Concern
- Pasta and meatballs draw repeated criticism for flavor and value
- Occasional rude or unhelpful staff interactions amid many positives
- Reported 3% surcharge and unclear pricing on extras
- Review patterns show signs of potential manipulation (high five-star share overall and enthusiastic staff-name clusters) which may not reflect typical diner experience
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$18-$28 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Choose combo meals ($14.75-$15.95) to include drink and side
- If ordering stromboli, ask for extra oven time to ensure doneness
- Budget $18-$28 per person for a full airport meal
Perfect For
- Quick pre-flight slice
- Solo travelers needing a fast meal
- Families with picky eaters
- Budget-minded airport dining
Location Insights
Area: Modern terminal food hall serving travelers; fast-paced, convenience-driven dining with national and local vendors.
Safety: High-traffic, well-patrolled airport concourse with strong lighting and constant staff presence.
Nearby: Located in Terminal B Headhouse Food Hall; near gates, coffee kiosks, and other quick-service spots.
East ElmhurstEast Elmhurst is a residential and commercial neighborhood adjacent to LaGuardia Airport, with a mix of long-term residents and transient populations due to the airport. Dining options here often cater to convenience and quick service, with many establishments located within or near the airport terminals.
LaGuardia Airport Terminal B Food HallThe Headhouse Food Hall in Terminal B is a modern dining area offering a variety of quick-service restaurants and casual eateries designed to serve the high volume of travelers passing through LaGuardia Airport. The atmosphere is fast-paced and functional, focusing on convenience and accessibility.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday05:00–21:00
Tuesday05:00–21:00
Wednesday05:00–21:00
Thursday05:00–21:00
Friday05:00–21:00
Saturday05:00–21:00
Sunday05:00–21:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →