Seemor

Jack & Charlie’s No. 118B+Worth Trying

Name: Jack & Charlie’s No. 118
Address: 118 Greenwich Ave, New York, NY 10011, New York, United States
Rating: 4.4

118 Greenwich Ave, New York, NY 10011 · Restaurant, American restaurant · 4.4/5 Google (258 reviews)

Reservations · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Polished West Village spot with crowd-pleasing steaks, duck meatloaf, and lively vibes; food is good more than great, service can be uneven, and pricing is a splurge with a removable 3% surcharge.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

Jack & Charlie's No. 118 delivers solid neighborhood dining with exceptional room design and strong food quality anchored by celebrated duck meatloaf and steaks. However, quality variation between dinner and brunch service and occasional service lapses prevent it from reaching grade A territory. The West Village location and lively atmosphere make it competitive with respected local favorites, though execution remains uneven enough to keep it from premium standing.

Restaurant Summary

The room feels warm and bustling with a handsome bar and stylish details that nod to old-school clubhouses. Expect close tables, rising volume, and upbeat service touches. One diner put it simply: "The steak was spot on and the room felt celebratory." Some nights run tighter than others, and a few guests noted awkward table moves or early nudges to turn the seat. The cooking leans elevated American with steakhouse instincts and modern accents. The celebrated duck meatloaf, seared steaks with peppercorn sauce, and a crisp branzino with yuzu cues define the vibe—classic comfort with subtle flair rather than theatrics. Brunch brings hearty plates like Benedicts, pancakes, and a popular burger; desserts and fries can be inconsistent, but when the kitchen clicks, it is polished and satisfying. Families will find enough familiar fare—burgers, pancakes, waffles, fries, and donuts—to keep most kids happy, though the room skews adult and festive. There is no dedicated kids menu, portions are generous, and prices track upscale West Village norms. If your crew needs very simple food, stick to the safer picks and skip the bolder signatures.

At a Glance

Stylish room and lively atmosphere for dates and celebrations
Duck meatloaf, steaks, and branzino draw consistent praise
Service can be uneven; occasional rushed turns and inattentive patches
3% surcharge appears on checks but can be removed on request
Occasional pest sightings reported historically; recent mentions are isolated

What Sets It Apart

signature_duck_meatloaf
prime_rib_service
sunset_menu_value
handsome_bar_program

What People Love

Signature duck meatloaf that feels special
Well-cooked steaks with bold peppercorn sauce
A handsome bar and upbeat, celebratory buzz
Hearty, satisfying brunch plates

Points of Concern

Pricing is a real splurge, especially steaks and prime rib; some find value lacking
Service inconsistencies: drink delays, table moves, and inattentive sections reported
Removable 3% surcharge can surprise guests if not spotted
Isolated reports of pests and HVAC/comfort issues; management generally responds

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost$78-118 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

For value, build a meal from Sunset Menu items like oysters and Caesar
Pair steaks with peppercorn sauce and a shareable side of whipped potatoes
For lighter mains, choose branzino or fusilli pesto

Perfect For

Celebrating a birthday with steak and cocktails
Date night in a lively West Village room
Team dinners where polished vibes matter
Happy hour bites on the Sunset Menu

Location Insights

Area: Chic West Village corridor attracting date nights, celebrations, and upscale neighborhood diners.

Safety: Generally safe, busy sidewalks, good lighting; occasional HVAC/comfort issues reported inside.

Nearby: Near boutiques, bars, and long-standing neighborhood institutions; convenient for strolling and bar-hopping.

West VillageThe West Village is characterized by its charming tree-lined streets, historic townhouses, and a strong sense of community. It offers a sophisticated yet relaxed dining environment with a mix of upscale restaurants, trendy cafes, and classic New York eateries, attracting both locals and tourists seeking quality and ambiance.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday16:00–22:00 Tuesday16:00–22:00 Wednesday16:00–22:00 Thursday16:00–22:00 Friday16:00–22:00 Saturday11:00–22:00 Sunday11:00–22:00

Available: Reservations, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →