Lively Spanish tapas spot in Edinburgh Old Town delivering flavorful small plates, friendly service, and attractive decor, with occasional consistency and policy hiccups; strong overall for groups and casual dates.
Cafe Andaluz Old Town delivers solid neighborhood dining through strong food quality and attentive, efficient service, with exceptional setting appeal that captures Old Town charm. However, inconsistent paella execution and occasional dietary communication lapses prevent a higher grade. The restaurant excels at what it does—casual Spanish tapas in a lively, welcoming space—but lacks the refinement or consistency to compete with the area's premier dining destinations.
One caveat: Paella consistency varies; some report soggy or bland rice while others praise it