Seemor

The Atlantic Bar & GrillB-Worth Trying

Name: The Atlantic Bar & Grill
Address: 2622 5062 N Lincoln Ave, Chicago, IL 60625, Chicago, United States
Rating: 4.5

2622 5062 N Lincoln Ave, Chicago, IL 60625 · Bar & grill · 4.5/5 Google (415 reviews)

Takeout

Lively Spurs-forward neighborhood pub with hearty Irish-leaning bar food, live music, and affordable pricing; great on match days but service and kitchen consistency can wobble when slammed.

Why it gets a B- for overall quality

The Atlantic Bar & Grill delivers dependable pub comfort with genuine neighborhood character—warm fireplace, live music stage, and solid execution on classics like fish and chips and Reuben sandwiches make it a natural gathering spot for Spurs fans and Irish pub seekers. Busy-night delays and occasional quality dips prevent higher marks, though generous portions and fair pricing reinforce its appeal as a casual, reliable local favorite rather than a destination dining experience.

Restaurant Summary

Walk in to a neighborhood pub that feels warm and bustling, with Spurs scarves, TVs tuned to the match, and a small stage glowing in the back room. Bartenders get shout-outs for keeping pints moving, and one guest raved that the fish and chips hit the spot. On packed game days the room can tilt from cozy to hectic fast, so expect lively crowds when Tottenham plays. The cooking leans classic Irish-American pub fare rather than cheffy flourishes. Think shepherd pie and Reuben, beer-battered fish, and waffle-fry Irish nachos. Regulars praise portions and prices, though a few busy-night visits suffered from slow tickets and undertopped appetizers. If you want dependable comfort over fancy plating, this menu is aimed squarely at pub-food cravings. Families will find it easy: the kids section covers tenders, mac, and grilled cheese, and most mains are familiar. If your crew comes on a big match or music night, arrive early, stake seats, and manage expectations on speed; off-peak is smoother for kid-friendly meals.

At a Glance

Energetic Spurs match hub with genuine neighborhood vibe
Hearty portions and fair pricing across pub staples
Back room and stage enable private events and live music
Kitchen delays and inconsistency during peak events
Occasional brusque service reports at the bar

What Sets It Apart

official_spurs_supporters_bar
live_music_stage_in_back_room
hearty_irish_pub_specials
private_event_friendly

What People Love

Matchday camaraderie that feels like a home base
Classic pub plates that satisfy without fuss
Friendly bartenders who remember regulars
Affordable checks with big portions

Points of Concern

During big matches and holidays, food waits can exceed 45 minutes and arrive cooler than ideal
A few reports of rude or inattentive bar service, especially when crowded
One isolated claim of off coleslaw and a hair in batter; not a repeated pattern

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleCounter With Seating Average Cost$28-40 per person ReservationsNot required

What to Order

Pescatarians: Fish n Chips or Greek Salad with tofu add-on
Vegetarians: Mixed Green or Caesar with crispy tofu, meat-free Irish nachos
Kids: Tenders with fries, Mac & Cheese, Grilled Cheese

Perfect For

Watching Premier League with fellow supporters
Casual weeknight comfort-food dinner
Live music with pints in a neighborhood setting
Private celebrations in a relaxed back room

Location Insights

Area: Casual, residential-leaning stretch of Lincoln Ave near Lincoln Square with sports fans and live-music patrons.

Safety: Generally safe, active foot traffic on event nights; typical North Side urban environment.

Nearby: Near Lincoln Square venues, bars, small shops; draws soccer fans and neighborhood regulars.

Lincoln SquareThe dining scene in Lincoln Square is eclectic and welcoming, featuring a blend of traditional American fare, ethnic cuisines, and trendy spots. The area is known for its walkability, local shops, and a community-oriented vibe that attracts diners looking for quality food in a relaxed setting.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday16:00–02:00 Tuesday16:00–02:00 Wednesday16:00–02:00 Thursday16:00–02:00 Friday16:00–02:00 Saturday11:00–02:00 Sunday11:00–02:00

Available: Takeout

View full analysis on Seemor →