Seemor
Mimi's Pizza (3rd Ave & 86th)B+Worth Trying
217 East 86th St, New York, NY 10028
· Pizza restaurant
· 4.7/5 Google (671 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Reliable Upper East Side slice shop with standout square/grandma slices and Denso pepperoni; tight space, fast counter service, great value, but delivery delays and occasional inconsistency can frustrate.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Mimi's Pizza delivers solid neighborhood quality through excellent food quality—particularly crisp grandma slices and standout pepperoni—paired with friendly, efficient counter service and exceptional value. However, inconsistent execution on delivery and occasional quality dips, combined with cramped physical space, prevent grade A territory. It's a reliable local favorite that exceeds typical slice-shop standards without reaching destination-level distinction.
Restaurant Summary
This Upper East Side slice shop feels tight but lively, with a quick-moving counter and the aroma of fresh pies pulling in passersby. Many rave about the square slices, calling out a "perfect crunch" and balanced sauce. Staff are often described as friendly and efficient, though the rush can make the place feel cramped. The cooking leans classic New York with a grandma-square twist: crisp bottoms, chewy centers, and toppings like cup-and-char pepperoni, vodka sauce, and spinach artichoke. It is elevated traditional rather than experimental, with consistent praise for flavor and value. Most satisfaction comes from in-store slices; delivery performance draws mixed feedback. Families do well here thanks to familiar pies, pasta, and heros, plus easy slice sharing. Cauliflower-crust personal pies help with gluten avoidance, and there are several vegetarian choices. Space is limited, so quick bites or takeout suit families best; kids who like simple cheese or pepperoni will find easy wins.
At a Glance
- Crisp, flavorful grandma slices and standout pepperoni
- Excellent value for Manhattan slice pricing
- Delivery and pickup delays during busy times
- Occasional inconsistency (bland or overcooked pies)
- Friendly, efficient counter team in-store
What Sets It Apart
- crisp grandma squares
- cup-and-char pepperoni
- budget-friendly slice pricing
What People Love
- That first crackly bite of the square slice
- Cup-and-char pepperoni richness
- Tangy, balanced red sauce
- Speed and ease of grab-and-go
Points of Concern
- Delivery can take far longer than quoted during peak hours
- Some reports of bland, dry, or overcooked pies indicate inconsistency
- Tight interior with few seats; can feel crowded
- Review patterns show normal owner responses; authenticity concerns are minimal overall
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$16-$26 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Choose square/grandma slices when available fresh
- Cauliflower crust is personal-size only; allow extra time
- Pair a slice with garlic knots for a filling budget meal
Perfect For
- Quick bite after museums or errands
- Casual weeknight takeout
- Solo snack at the counter
- Budget-friendly group slice run
Location Insights
Area: Dense residential Upper East Side corridor serving commuters, families, and museum-goers; practical and fast-paced.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, high foot traffic along 86th Street commercial strip.
Nearby: Near 86th St retail, Second Ave Subway, and museums like the Met and Guggenheim within a longer walk.
Upper East SideThe dining scene is characterized by a mix of upscale restaurants, classic New York delis, and casual eateries catering to well-heeled locals and visitors. The atmosphere is generally refined and quiet, with a focus on quality and tradition rather than nightlife or trendiness.
Lenox HillLenox Hill is known for its proximity to major hospitals and medical centers, attracting healthcare workers and patients. Dining options here include a blend of casual and upscale venues, often frequented by professionals and neighborhood residents seeking convenience and quality.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday10:00–23:00
Tuesday10:00–02:00
Wednesday10:00–04:00
Thursday10:00–04:00
Friday10:00–04:00
Saturday10:00–04:00
Sunday10:00–04:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →