Seemor
Slice House by Tony GemignaniB-Worth Trying
135 Parrott St, San Leandro, CA 94577
· Pizza restaurant, Chicken wings restaurant, Italian restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (431 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Casual slice-focused pizzeria with strong Detroit and NY-style pies, but recent service delays, cold pie complaints, and operational changes create inconsistency; best when dining in at off-peak times.
Why it gets a B- for overall quality
Slice House by Tony Gemignani delivers excellent pizza when conditions align—Detroit and NY-style slices earn genuine praise for crust quality and toppings when served fresh and hot. However, inconsistent execution across timing and order channels, combined with variable service attentiveness and recent quality decline reports, prevents a higher grade. Best experienced as a casual neighborhood slice stop during off-peak hours rather than a destination pizzeria.
Restaurant Summary
Step into a casual slice shop that feels lively and local when the ovens are humming and the game is on. Reviewers rave about thick-edged Detroit squares and big NY slices, with one noting the crust delivered a crisp-chewy bite and a sauce that sang. Service warmth varies by shift, but when the team clicks, the vibe is welcome and easy for families and regulars. The cooking leans classic American-Italian with options across styles—NY, Grandma, and Detroit—focusing on well-sourced toppings, sweet-leaning red sauce, and hearty portions rather than culinary tricks. It suits diners who want dependable crowd-pleasers like Wiseguy and Motorhead or a couple of slices with a beer. Fresh, dine-in pies shine most; delivery and late rushes can dull the edges. Families fare well here thanks to by-the-slice flexibility, cheese and pepperoni staples, and shareable wings. That said, veg-forward choices by the slice can be scarce at times, and timing matters: arrive a bit off-peak for hotter pies and a smoother experience.
At a Glance
- Detroit and NY-style pizzas impress when fresh
- Slices are large and good for casual meals
- Frequent reports of late orders and cold pies at peak times
- Parking around the block can be tough
- Delivery experiences vary; dine-in or prompt pickup yields better results
What Sets It Apart
- multiple pizza styles under one roof
- huge by-the-slice portions
- local sports-watching vibe
What People Love
- That crisp-chewy crust when hot
- Thick, satisfying Detroit corners
- Friendly interactions with standout staff on good nights
- Being able to try multiple flavors by the slice
- Local, easygoing atmosphere
Points of Concern
- Cold or lukewarm pizzas reported across multiple months, especially delivery or late pickups
- Order readiness delays even with pre-ordering during lunch and dinner rushes
- Limited by-the-slice vegetarian options at times; substitutions and dip charges frustrate some
- Review patterns show signs of timing-driven inconsistency that may not reflect the best case
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$26-40 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Based on review mentions, ask which pizzas just came out for best texture
- Check slice counter for vegetarian options; whole pie if selection is limited
Perfect For
- Game-day slices and beers
- Casual family dinner without reservations
- Quick lunch with a hearty slice
- Takeout when ordering off-peak
Location Insights
Area: Central San Leandro spot with local foot traffic, casual bars, and everyday services; draws families and game watchers.
Safety: Generally safe with steady foot traffic; occasional cleanliness complaints outside reported by reviewers.
Nearby: Near downtown shops and casual bars; convenient for pickup and quick meals; parking can be competitive nearby.
Downtown San LeandroDowntown San Leandro is a revitalized area featuring a mix of historic buildings and modern developments, with a growing dining scene that includes casual eateries, cafes, and some specialty restaurants. The atmosphere is community-oriented and accessible, attracting locals looking for convenient dining and social spots.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–21:00
Tuesday11:00–21:00
Wednesday11:00–21:00
Thursday11:00–21:00
Friday11:00–22:00
Saturday11:00–22:00
Sunday11:00–21:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →