Seemor

Catch n' ChopB+Worth Trying

Name: Catch n' Chop
Address: 1600 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10128, New York, United States
Rating: 4.5

1600 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10128 · Steak house, Seafood restaurant · 4.5/5 Google (135 reviews)

Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Neighborhood steak-and-seafood spot with classy vibes, strong steaks, and lively bar; expect occasional slow service and premium add-ons.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

Catch n' Chop delivers solid neighborhood steakhouse performance with strong food quality on signature dry-aged cuts and excellent service knowledge, particularly in wine and cocktail guidance. However, inconsistent execution on seafood and sides, combined with slower pacing between courses, prevents the grade A territory that its best moments approach. The attractive, recently renovated room and loyal following position it competitively among Upper East Side dining options, though premium add-ons and occasional service lapses keep it from exceptional standing.

Restaurant Summary

The room feels classy and dim, with a lively bar that doubles as a neighborhood hangout. Guests describe servers by name and note touches like pretzel breadsticks. One diner put it simply: "Service was warm and the steak arrived perfectly pink." The setting lands between romantic steakhouse and casual bar energy, which regulars enjoy. In the kitchen, the approach is elevated steakhouse with modern accents rather than full-on experimentation. Dry-aged cuts are the headline, supported by a raw bar, tuna tartare with yuzu, and scallops over truffle mushroom risotto. When the line is humming, the food sings; on off nights, seafood doneness and pacing can wobble. Expect premium add-ons for sauces and sides, but ingredients are clearly the focus. Families fit in just fine. You will find kid-approachable dishes like burgers, roast chicken, mac and cheese, and waffles at brunch, alongside steak and fries. There is no kids menu noted, but portions are shareable and staff are accommodating, so young eaters should be comfortable here.

At a Glance

Dry-aged steaks are consistently praised for doneness and seasoning
Attractive room with lively bar and occasional live jazz
Pacing can be slow between courses and at the bar
Premium pricing on add-ons (sauces, sides) raises totals
Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food

What Sets It Apart

steak_and_seafood_under_one_roof
live_jazz_nights
neighborhood_date_spot
robust_raw_bar

What People Love

Steaks cooked exactly to temp
Scallops with truffle risotto
Friendly, named servers and floor managers
Gorgeous, softly lit dining room and lively bar

Points of Concern

Service speed varies; multiple reports of long waits for drinks and mains
Seafood execution can be inconsistent (halibut, octopus reports)
Add-on pricing (sauces $6, sides $14-19) may feel steep
Review patterns show minor promotional tone in a few posts but overall authenticity is solid

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost$80-110 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

Share two sides per two guests (spinach, mushrooms) to control spend
If sensitive to spice, ask about the heat level in Lobster Diavolo Bucatini
Choose one sauce for steak to minimize add-on costs

Perfect For

Date night with a shared porterhouse
Neighborhood cocktails and appetizers at the bar
Celebration dinners with family or friends
Brunch with both savory and sweet options

Location Insights

Area: Resident-heavy Upper East Side corridor; after-work cocktails, date nights, and family dinners.

Safety: Well-lit, high foot traffic, generally safe even late.

Nearby: Near neighborhood bars, boutiques, and residential blocks; not a tourist core.

YorkvilleYorkville offers a more relaxed and residential atmosphere compared to the rest of the Upper East Side, with a growing number of casual dining options, neighborhood cafes, and family-friendly restaurants. The area is known for its safe streets, accessibility, and a community-oriented dining scene that balances traditional and contemporary cuisines.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday15:00–00:00 Tuesday15:00–00:00 Wednesday15:00–00:00 Thursday15:00–00:00 Friday11:00–01:00 Saturday11:00–01:00 Sunday11:00–00:00

Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →