Seemor
Famous Calabria PizzaB-Worth Trying
27 St James Pl, New York, NY 10038
· Pizza restaurant, Italian restaurant, Pizza delivery
· 4.5/5 Google (714 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Creative New York slice shop near the Brooklyn Bridge with lots of toppings and friendly vibes; quality ranges from great specialty slices to inconsistent basics, service can be uneven.
Why it gets a B- for overall quality
Famous Calabria Pizza delivers reliable neighborhood appeal through strong specialty slice execution and excellent value, but inconsistent quality on basics like plain slices and dough prevents a higher grade. Friendly staff and convenient downtown location make it a solid casual stop, though limited seating and occasional service gaps keep it from competing with the area's premier pizza destinations.
Restaurant Summary
A downtown slice shop with creative specialty pies and a steady flow of locals, office workers, and bridge-walkers. Guests describe the staff as friendly and welcoming, with big slices and cozy decor that make for an easy stop. One diner summed it up: "The buffalo chicken slice had great crunch and sauce, perfect for a quick bite." The cooking leans classic New York with Italian‑American twists: vodka sauce on Margherita, Caesar salad slices, and hearty ranch drizzles. When you aim at the specialties, the flavors pop; when you stick to the plain slice, results can vary. Think elevated traditional over avant‑garde, with generous portions and combos that feed a crowd without fuss. For families, it is a solid pick. Kids can stick to plain cheese or pepperoni, chicken fingers, fries, or a simple pasta, while adventurous eaters grab saucy specialties. Seating is limited but workable for a quick, casual meal.
At a Glance
- Specialty slices (Buffalo, vodka-based, Tri-colore) earn strong praise
- Big portions and combo deals provide good value
- Plain slice, sauce balance, and calzone/hero quality vary
- Service can be curt or disorganized at times
- Expect limited seating and counter service only
What Sets It Apart
- creative_specialty_slices
- grandma_square_offerings
- combo_deals_for_groups
What People Love
- Crunchy crust with flavorful specialty toppings
- Hearty, oversized slices
- Friendly counter staff on good days
- Convenient location near Brooklyn Bridge
Points of Concern
- Quality of basics varies (plain slice, sauce, dough) with mixed reports
- Inconsistent service: delayed orders and occasional rudeness cited
- Some items feel reheated or lukewarm during rush
- Review patterns show marketing-style praise in places; overall data seems mostly authentic
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$22-$36 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Choose a specialty pie over plain if you value flavor pop
- Use combo specials for 2–4 people to optimize cost
- Vegetarians have strong choices (Margherita, Bianca, Veggie Lovers) and a gluten-free 12 inch option
Perfect For
- Casual post-bridge walk refuel
- Quick solo slice at the window counter
- Budget-friendly group share with combo deals
- Families wanting simple kid-friendly options
Location Insights
Area: Downtown, near civic centers and the Brooklyn Bridge; mix of residents, office workers, and tourists.
Safety: Generally busy and well-trafficked; typical downtown safety with constant foot flow daytime into evening.
Nearby: Close to Brooklyn Bridge promenade, Chinatown, City Hall, and residential towers; steady takeout and foot traffic.
Financial DistrictThe Financial District has evolved from a primarily business-focused area to a vibrant mixed-use neighborhood with a diverse dining scene ranging from quick casual spots to upscale restaurants. The atmosphere is a blend of bustling daytime activity with office workers and a quieter, more residential vibe in the evenings and weekends.
South Street SeaportSouth Street Seaport is a historic waterfront area within the Financial District known for its maritime heritage, shopping, and dining options. It attracts tourists and locals alike, offering a scenic and lively dining environment with views of the East River and Brooklyn Bridge.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday10:00–21:00
Tuesday10:00–21:00
Wednesday10:00–21:00
Thursday10:00–21:00
Friday10:00–21:00
Saturday10:00–21:00
Sunday10:00–21:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →