Reliable Upper East Side slice shop with wide variety and friendly counter service; sweet-leaning sauce divides opinions and occasional inconsistency on reheated slices.
Original Roma Pizza earns its grade through strong food quality and exceptional service attentiveness, delivering the classic UES slice-shop experience with friendly counter staff and quick turnaround. However, inconsistent execution on reheated slices and a sauce profile that divides opinion prevent it from reaching higher territory. For casual neighborhood pizza and families seeking straightforward comfort food with good value, it's a reliable local choice.
One caveat: Red sauce sweetness divides opinions; some prefer a saltier profile