Casual Upper West Side spot for excellent falafel and solid kebabs at fair prices; some inconsistency on shawarma and occasional prep/cleanliness quibbles.
Sido Falafel & More earns a solid grade B through strong food quality anchored by exceptional falafel and genuinely warm, attentive service, but inconsistent execution on shawarma and modest casual decor prevent higher standing. This is a reliable neighborhood counter spot worth visiting for quick, friendly Middle Eastern fare—just don't expect destination-level polish or consistency across the full menu.
One caveat: Shawarma can be dry or reheated from a container per several reports