Delivery · Takeout
Solid late-night NYC slice shop with standout margherita and friendly counter vibe, but recurring complaints about overcharging and inconsistent service/value mean vigilant customers will have the best experience.
Romano Pizza delivers dependable neighborhood slice-shop quality with a crisp margherita that earns genuine fan loyalty and a warm, bustling counter vibe. Food quality is good but shows variability across slice types and timing, while service inconsistency—friendly moments mixed with occasional rudeness and unanswered phones—prevents higher marks. The corner location and late-night hours build habit, but this is a solid neighborhood stop rather than a destination worth traveling for.
On a busy Kips Bay corner, this slice shop feels warm and bustling, the kind of place where the counter crew swaps quick smiles while pies rotate through the oven. Reviewers rave about the margherita slice and a crust that snaps just right, with one diner saying it delivered a "crackly bite and bright sauce." Service is usually friendly, but a few accounts describe curt interactions and spotty phone etiquette, so it pays to stay patient but direct. The cooking leans classic NYC by-the-slice with a few playful riffs—think vodka and penne pies rather than chefly showpieces. Expect comfort-first pizza and generous portions at wallet-friendly menu prices. Quality is generally good, though a minority call out bland veggie slices or sweet sauce. Best results come fresh from the oven and reheated to preference; ask for extra crisp if you like a firmer base. Families do well here thanks to simple, kid-pleasing choices like plain cheese, chicken fingers and fries, and straightforward pastas and subs. If someone in the crew is picky, stick to cheese or margherita and skip more loaded specialty slices. There is no dedicated kids menu, but portions are shareable and prices are friendly for a quick family bite.
Area: Busy Midtown East/Kips Bay corridor with office workers, residents, and late-night foot traffic; casual, on-the-go energy.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit avenues with steady pedestrian flow; typical Midtown vigilance advised.
Nearby: Near 3rd Ave bars, nail salons, and everyday retail; handy for commuters and neighborhood errands.
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →