Seemor
Maui PieBWorth Trying
1280 S Kihei Rd #101, Kihei, HI 96753
· Bakery
· 4.6/5 Google (587 reviews)
Takeout
Locally loved pie bakery with standout fruit and cream pies, friendly service, and fair Hawaii pricing; minor inconsistencies on cream pies and availability.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Maui Pie delivers solid neighborhood bakery quality through excellent fruit pies and flaky crusts paired with warm, attentive counter service. Mostly consistent execution supports repeat visits, though occasional cream pie texture variation and limited seating prevent higher distinction. A reliable local favorite for casual island baking rather than a destination experience.
Restaurant Summary
Bright and welcoming in a Kihei shopping center, Maui Pie feels like a neighborhood spot where the counter team is genuinely warm. A visitor summed it up: "Cute and clean with buttery crusts". Expect a casual counter setup, friendly service, and fresh-baked aromas that pull you in. The baking leans classic American pies with island touches rather than culinary theatrics. Think fruit-forward crumbles, coconut-rich haupia, and a deeply comforting chicken pot pie. The approach is tradition-first with local flavors, ideal for travelers seeking a taste of Maui without fuss. Most feedback raves about fruit pies and crust texture, while a few note cream pies can skew custardy or extra sweet. Families fit right in. Kids gravitate to slices, cookies, and the lilikoi muffin, while mini pies are fun to share. With fruit pies that happen to be vegan and simple savory options, it is easy to please mixed palates. Do note that favorites can sell out, so call ahead for minis or whole pies.
At a Glance
- Excellent fruit pies and flaky crusts with local flavors
- Friendly, fast counter service with preorder options
- Popular items sell out; availability varies by day
- Cream pies can be sweeter or more custardy than expected
What Sets It Apart
- local_flavor_pies_haupia_lilikoi
- multiple_sizes_slice_mini_large
- take_and_bake_savory_pies
What People Love
- Crust that balances flaky and tender
- Island flavors like lilikoi and haupia
- Mini, slice, and whole pie flexibility
- Warm, welcoming counter interactions
- Pies that travel well for days
Points of Concern
- Cream pie texture and sweetness vary; some prefer less custard and lighter whipped cream
- Minis are petite; one reviewer felt poor value vs slice
- Holiday rush can lead to sell-outs or rare bake issues; preorder early
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$13-$20 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Choose fruit pies if seeking vegan options
- Add a scoop of Roselani vanilla to berry slices
- Preorder quiche; it is listed as preorder-only
Perfect For
- Picking up dessert for a beach gathering
- A quick sweet stop after lunch in Kihei
- Holiday or birthday pie preorders
- Comfort-food take-and-bake dinner with chicken pot pie
Location Insights
Area: Busy Kihei strip-center setting catering to beachgoers and locals; casual and convenient.
Safety: Well-trafficked shopping center with lighting and steady foot traffic; generally safe.
Nearby: Near South Kihei Road, adjacent shops and quick eats; beach parks a short drive away.
KiheiKihei is a laid-back beach town with a strong local community and a steady influx of tourists. The dining scene is casual and diverse, featuring local Hawaiian cuisine, seafood, and quick-service eateries. The atmosphere is relaxed and family-friendly, with many establishments catering to beachgoers and vacationers.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday07:00–20:00
Tuesday07:00–20:00
Wednesday07:00–20:00
Thursday07:00–20:00
Friday07:00–20:00
Saturday11:00–20:00
Sunday13:00–18:00
Available: Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →