Seemor
FarinellaC-Proceed Cautiously
1796 Broadway, New York, NY 10019
· Pizza restaurant, Coffee shop, Pizza delivery
· 4.5/5 Google (731 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Convenient Roman-style slice spot near Columbus Circle with mixed quality, quick counter service, and fair-to-poor value depending on slice freshness; good for a fast bite, inconsistent for destination pizza.
Why it gets a C- for overall quality
Farinella's prime location near Central Park and creative Roman-style toppings appeal to park-goers seeking convenience, but inconsistent slice temperature and texture across visits significantly undermines the experience. Service attitudes vary unpredictably, and pricing feels steep for smaller portions, making this a location-dependent grab-and-go option rather than a reliable neighborhood favorite.
Restaurant Summary
On a busy corner by Columbus Circle, Farinella draws park-goers for Roman-style square slices and a bustling counter-service vibe. Guests split on execution: some praise crisp, topping-heavy squares, while others grumble about lukewarm reheats and service attitude. One diner summed it up: "Great for a quick bite if the slice is hot." The cooking leans elevated-traditional Italian, with toppings like cacio e pepe, buffalo mozzarella, and black truffle on a Roman al taglio base—creative within the canon rather than showy. It suits people seeking a fast, location-convenient meal over a destination pie, and quality rides on timing and freshness. For families, the menu is naturally friendly: margherita, pepperoni, fries, and simple salads are safe picks, plus cannoli and tiramisu. There is no clear kids menu, but familiar items abound. Portions feel modest for price, so budget accordingly and ask for slices to be heated hot.
At a Glance
- Prime location steps from Central Park and theaters
- Creative Roman-style toppings like cacio e pepe and truffle
- Inconsistent slice temperature and texture across visits
- Prices higher than typical slice shops for smaller portions
- Reports of 20% service charge for dine-in by some guests
What Sets It Apart
- roman_al_taglio_format
- central_park_proximity
- creative_italian_toppings
What People Love
- Easy, fast counter experience by the park
- Topping-forward pepperoni and specialty slices
- Cute, Capri-like decor
- Reliable desserts like cannoli and tiramisu
Points of Concern
- Temperature inconsistency: multiple lukewarm or hard crust reports, especially at busy times
- Value complaints: small slices and location premium pricing
- Early closing and delivery cancellations reported by several reviewers
- Service attitude varies—some friendly, others dismissive or confused
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$24-38 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Choose Margherita or Pepperoni for kids; add fries. For fans of bold flavors, try Tartufo Nero or Cacio e Pepe. Salads at $12-14 balance a slice-heavy meal.
Perfect For
- Quick pre-show bite near Columbus Circle
- Casual park picnic pickup
- Solo lunch on the go
- Families wanting simple pizza options
Location Insights
Area: High-footfall, tourist-heavy corner by Columbus Circle and Central Park; strong grab-and-go demand.
Safety: Generally safe, well-patrolled, heavy foot traffic day and evening.
Nearby: Near Central Park, Time Warner Center, Broadway theaters, hotels, and offices.
Theater DistrictThe Theater District is vibrant and lively, centered around Broadway theaters and entertainment venues. Dining options range from casual eateries to upscale restaurants catering to pre- and post-show crowds, as well as office workers and visitors. The area is busy throughout the day and night, with a dynamic social atmosphere.
nullnull
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday08:00–21:00
Tuesday08:00–21:00
Wednesday08:00–21:00
Thursday08:00–21:00
Friday08:00–21:00
Saturday08:00–21:00
Sunday08:00–21:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →