Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Atmospheric crypt cafe serving well-executed, seasonal Modern European plates at fair City prices, with unique setting, friendly service, and a few concerns around pricing clarity and occasional bland dishes.
Café Below delivers A-grade performance through exceptional historic crypt ambiance and solid food quality with seasonal, homemade cooking that resonates with regulars. Consistency shows some variation in execution and flavor intensity, while moderate review authenticity concerns create slight uncertainty in assessment. The hidden gem factor and loyal following position it as a worthwhile neighborhood destination, though it falls short of the distinctive excellence needed for grade A territory.
Down a set of steep steps beneath St Mary-le-Bow, the room feels warm and atmospheric, part crypt, part cozy cafe. Diners describe it as a hidden gem where the bustle of Cheapside fades away: "It felt like we found a secret spot under the church." Service trends friendly and quick, though a few guests noted the tiny facilities and echo of the vaulted space. The cooking leans modern European with Mediterranean accents: think roast salmon with herbs, hearty casseroles, and vegan tagines. The culinary approach feels elevated but familiar: seasonal, homemade dishes over theatrics, with a menu that changes often. Most praise the freshness and balance, while a minority found flavors muted or portions light for price; value is generally strong for the City, but watch for eat-in vs takeaway price differences. For families, the breakfast side is kid-friendly with pancakes, eggs, and toast, and simple salads can work for cautious eaters. There are vegetarian and vegan mains, though reviews and the menu suggest no vegan dessert currently. If you have picky diners, choose breakfast or straightforward plates and confirm prices at the counter before you commit.
Area: Historic financial district with heavy weekday footfall, corporate offices, and iconic churches; caters to office workers and visitors.
Safety: Generally very safe, high foot traffic in daytime, well-patrolled business district.
Nearby: Near Cheapside retail, St Mary-le-Bow church, close to Bank and St Pauls; popular for business lunches and sightseeing stops.
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →