Delivery · Takeout
Destination pie shop for comforting savory and sweet pies with standout crust and quick counter service; a few consistency and sweetness complaints but overall a crowd-pleaser.
Pop Pie Co. delivers solid neighborhood appeal with excellent crust quality and flavorful fillings that justify its loyal following, but inconsistent execution—occasional under-heated pies and variable sweetness—prevents higher-grade territory. Friendly, attentive service and fast-moving lines make it a reliable casual stop for pie lovers, though the modest cafe setting lacks distinction beyond its convenient corner location.
On a lively University Heights corner, Pop Pie Co. feels warm and bustling without the fuss. Lines move fast, staff offer quick suggestions, and slices arrive hot when requested. One diner summed it up: "The crust was buttery and the filling generous," while another noted the casual counter flow and easy outdoor seats for people-watching. The cooking leans classic comfort with a few global twists—think Green Hog and Cheese with mild chiles, creamy Classic Chicken, and a bright, custardy Key Lime. Most praise the flaky all-butter crust and hearty portions; occasional critiques mention under-heated pies, a dry steak pie here and there, or sweets that run very sweet. Value feels fair for the quality and portion size, especially if you pair a savory pie with a side and finish with a slice. Families fare well: the menu has plenty kids will eat—chicken pie, mashed potatoes, cookies, and fruit-forward slices—plus outdoor seating and an easygoing vibe. There is a vegan curry pie and vegetarian quiche, but no gluten-free crusts, so plan accordingly if that is essential.
Area: Lively, walkable neighborhood hub with cafes and boutiques drawing locals and casual visitors.
Safety: Generally safe with steady foot traffic; occasional parking and curbside congestion typical of busy corners.
Nearby: Near other eateries and an artisan ice cream shop; street-facing corner with outdoor seating.
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →