Seemor
Bene PizzaBWorth Trying
937 Hildebrand Ln #104, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110
· Pizza restaurant, Italian restaurant, Restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (182 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Excellent pizza and pastas with a cozy, casual vibe—expect moderate prices and outdoor seating only.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Bene Pizza delivers solid neighborhood quality anchored by excellent thin-crust pizza and creative toppings, with attentive service and strong family appeal. However, occasional consistency dips and weather-dependent outdoor-only seating prevent it from reaching higher territory. A reliable local favorite rather than a destination establishment.
Restaurant Summary
Bene Pizza is a beloved Bainbridge Island spot known for its crispy thin-crust pizzas, inventive toppings, and a laid-back, family-friendly atmosphere. The menu balances classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese with creative options such as pear & gorgonzola and kale pizzas, all crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Outdoor seating and a cozy vibe make it a go-to for locals and a convenient stop for ferry travelers. The culinary approach here is elevated traditional—think familiar Italian comfort food with a few creative twists. While the innovation level isn't avant-garde, dishes like the creamy pesto pasta and unique pizza combinations keep things interesting for adventurous eaters, while still offering plenty for those who prefer the classics. Generous portions and moderate prices make it a solid value, especially for families and groups. For families with kids, Bene Pizza shines: the menu features butter noodles, cheese and pepperoni pizzas, and other approachable options that consistently win over younger diners. Reviews highlight positive family experiences and group meals, and the menu confirms a strong selection of kid-friendly choices. Just note that all seating is outdoors, so plan accordingly for weather.
At a Glance
- Excellent thin-crust pizza with creative and classic options.
- Kid-friendly menu with butter noodles and familiar pizzas.
- Friendly staff and fast takeout service.
- No indoor seating—outdoor only, which can be weather-dependent.
- Occasional complaints about salad portion size and inflexible customization.
What Sets It Apart
- creative_pizza_toppings
- outdoor_seating
- family_friendly_menu
What People Love
- The crispy, flavorful pizza crust and fresh toppings
- Unique combinations like pear & gorgonzola pizza
- Friendly, accommodating staff
- Kid-friendly menu and group-friendly portions
- Quick, reliable takeout service
Points of Concern
- No indoor seating—outdoor dining only, which can be uncomfortable in bad weather
- Some complaints about small salad portions relative to price
- Occasional reports of inflexible customization or staff rudeness
- A few recent reviews note dips in quality or consistency
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$32-40 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Opt for pizzas or pastas for best value and portion size.
- Butter noodles and cheese pizza are safe bets for kids.
- Try the pear & gorgonzola or kale pizza for something unique.
Perfect For
- Grabbing a quality pizza before catching the ferry
- Family dinners with picky and adventurous eaters alike
- Casual group gatherings or outdoor meals
- Locals seeking a reliable pizza night spot
Location Insights
Area: Downtown Bainbridge Island is a walkable, relaxed area with a mix of locals and visitors, featuring small businesses and casual eateries.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, and maintained; high foot traffic during ferry hours.
Nearby: Near ferry terminal, grocery stores, and boutique shops; attracts both residents and tourists.
Bainbridge IslandAn upscale, picturesque island community with a sophisticated dining scene, featuring farm-to-table restaurants, artisan cafes, and a mix of local and high-end culinary offerings.
Hildebrand AreaA residential neighborhood with a quiet, suburban feel, likely featuring clustered residential units and proximity to local amenities.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday15:30–20:00
Tuesday15:30–20:00
Wednesday15:30–20:00
Thursday15:30–20:00
Friday15:30–20:00
Saturday15:30–20:00
Sunday15:30–20:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →