Seemor
Settimi's Gelato
367 B St Armands Cir, Sarasota, FL 34236
· Ice cream shop, Espresso bar
· 4.8/5 Google (749 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Excellent, creamy gelato with many flavors and sorbetto options in a busy St. Armands Circle spot; minor service hiccups and delivery packaging issues do occur.
Restaurant Summary
Set within the hum of St. Armands Circle, Settimi's Gelato feels like a sweet pit stop where lines move, samples flow, and cups gleam with rich Italian flavors. Guests describe creamy, intensely flavored gelato and a counter team that often offers tastings, though peak rushes can slow shakes and fray tempers. One fan put it simply: "Like being back in Italy with a cup in hand." The culinary approach is classic Italian gelato—dense, silky, and focused on ingredients over tricks. Think pistachio, nocciola, and stracciatella, plus affogatos and shakes. It suits dessert lovers who value authentic flavors over novelty; espresso can be hit-or-miss, but the chocolate profiles shine. Expect tourist-area pricing that feels fair given quality and location. Families are well served here: straightforward flavors, waffle cones, and kid-pleasers alongside multiple vegan sorbettos and some dairy-free options. Space can tighten during rushes, but a few outdoor tables help. If you are with picky eaters, start with classic chocolate or vanilla-adjacent choices and sample before committing.
At a Glance
- Creamy, authentic Italian-style gelato with standout pistachio, nocciola, and chocolate
- Friendly sampling culture and clean, well-kept shop
- Delivery packaging and melt issues reported by multiple customers
- Occasional rude or rushed counter interactions during peak times
- Espresso quality inconsistent; one review described bitter, burnt notes
What Sets It Apart
- classic_italian_gelato_focus
- affogato_with_real_espresso
- broad_sorbetto_selection
What People Love
- Silky texture that feels true to Italy
- Deep chocolate intensity without cloying sweetness
- Nostalgic nut flavors like pistachio and hazelnut
- Sampling that helps pick the perfect combo
- Location that makes dessert part of the outing
Points of Concern
- Delivery and to-go packaging can warp or leak, leading to melted product
- Occasional service lapses under pressure, including brusque tone and slow shakes
- Some flavors divide opinion (birthday cake, dulce de leche) compared to classics
- Pricing is higher than Italy and typical neighborhoods due to location
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$10-$15 per person
ReservationsNot required
Perfect For
- After-dinner stroll on St. Armands Circle
- Quick sweet break between beach and boutiques
- Families seeking classic flavors with vegan sorbettos
- Affogato lovers wanting gelato plus espresso
Location Insights
Area: Upscale, tourist-friendly shopping and dining district with steady foot traffic, ideal for strolling and desserts.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, and maintained with busy sidewalks into the evening.
Nearby: Surrounded by boutiques, cafes, and other dessert spots; beach and Lido Key attractions nearby.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday10:30–22:00
Tuesday10:30–22:00
Wednesday10:30–22:00
Thursday10:30–22:00
Friday10:30–22:00
Saturday10:30–22:00
Sunday11:00–22:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →