A beloved University District coffee spot with excellent espresso, fair prices, cozy vibes, and occasional service warmth inconsistencies.
Herkimer Coffee delivers solid neighborhood cafe performance through exceptional espresso and milk drink quality paired with outstanding value for Seattle specialty coffee. Service warmth varies by staff and timing, and limited seating constrains the experience during peak hours, preventing the higher distinction needed for grade A territory. The loyal local following and reliable drink execution make it a worthwhile stop for quality coffee at fair prices.
One caveat: Service can feel aloof or unwelcoming on some visits, even when not busy