Seemor
Olde City Cheesesteaks & BrewB+Worth Trying
576 9th Ave, New York, NY 10036
· Restaurant, Bar, Cheesesteak restaurant
· 4.7/5 Google (477 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Solid Philly-style cheesesteaks and sports-bar energy with strong happy-hour value; service and takeout consistency can wobble during peaks.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew delivers reliable neighborhood appeal through authentic, juicy cheesesteaks and attentive bartender service, with strong value at lunch and happy hour. However, inconsistent execution across orders and tight seating during peak times prevent it from reaching higher territory. It's a solid sports-bar destination for casual dining rather than a standout culinary experience.
Restaurant Summary
A compact Hell's Kitchen sports bar where cheesesteaks, cold beer, and TVs set the tone, the room feels warm and bustling without taking itself too seriously. Staff shout-outs are common—"our bartender was lovely and on it"—though a few nights see service hiccups. Game days can get crowded and standing-room happens near the door. The culinary approach leans classic Philly comfort with small twists: think authentic cheesesteaks, wings, pretzels, and a few sauced variations rather than chefly theatrics. Happy-hour and lunch bundles deliver strong value, while cocktails price like Midtown. If you want a dependable bar sandwich and a pint while the game is on, this hits the brief. For families, it is reasonably kid-friendly: burgers, tenders, plain fries, and simple cheesesteaks are easy wins, though there is no kids menu. The menu shows two vegetarian sandwiches but no true vegan options, so plan accordingly. Peak game times are loud and seating is limited; off-peak visits suit families better.
At a Glance
- Juicy, authentic-leaning cheesesteaks praised by many Philly-savvy diners
- Strong value at lunch and happy hour (notably the $20 bundle)
- Service inconsistency reported during busy periods
- Limited seating; crowded on major game days
- Very limited vegan choices; vegetarian options exist
What Sets It Apart
- Philly-style focus in Midtown
- House-baked Philly pretzels
- Value-forward lunch/happy-hour bundles
What People Love
- Hot, flavorful cheesesteaks that feel close to Philly
- Friendly bartenders who remember regulars
- House-baked pretzels and crispy spring rolls
- Bundle deals that make Midtown feel affordable
Points of Concern
- Service can be inattentive or brusque on busy shifts; a few rude encounters reported
- Order errors and takeout inconsistency appear occasionally
- Cocktails and wine feel pricey for a bar setting ($15-16 reported)
- Limited seating and blocked views during big games can frustrate diners
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$40-52 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Try the Special with broccoli rabe and provolone for a classic South Philly profile
- Pair City Fries with a lighter beer to balance richness
- Vegetarians: City Shroomin’ or Veggie Combo are your best bets
Perfect For
- Watching a big game with a cheesesteak and beer
- Casual pre-theater bite nearby
- Solo bar meal with friendly service
- Late-night happy hour deal hunting
Location Insights
Area: Bustling Midtown West block serving office workers, theatergoers, and tourists; lively bar-and-bites corridor.
Safety: Generally busy and well-patrolled; high foot traffic with typical Midtown late-night bustle.
Nearby: Near Port Authority, theaters, and bars; strong game-day crowds and after-work drinkers influence pace.
Hell's KitchenHell's Kitchen offers a vibrant dining scene with a variety of casual eateries, trendy restaurants, and bars catering to both locals and tourists. The area is lively, with a mix of after-work crowds and theater audiences, reflecting its proximity to the Theater District and Times Square.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–02:00
Tuesday11:00–02:00
Wednesday11:00–02:00
Thursday11:00–02:00
Friday11:00–02:00
Saturday11:00–02:00
Sunday11:00–02:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →