Seemor
The Mermaid InnBWorth Trying
227 10th Ave, New York, NY 10011
· Seafood restaurant, American restaurant, Restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (410 reviews)
Reservations · Takeout · Outdoor seating
High-energy Chelsea seafood spot with standout happy hour and attentive service; solid raw bar, mixed execution on hot dishes, premium pricing.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
The Mermaid Inn delivers solid neighborhood dining anchored by exceptional service attentiveness and a appealing High Line-adjacent setting that makes it a natural stop for Chelsea visitors. However, inconsistent execution on cooked dishes and seasoning combined with documented raw seafood safety concerns prevent a higher grade—stick to the oysters and simpler preparations where the kitchen excels.
Restaurant Summary
A Chelsea seafood mainstay where the room feels warm and bustling and the staff keeps a friendly, professional rhythm. Guests rave about the oyster deals and attentive servers, with one diner noting, "they checked on us without hovering." If you are strolling the High Line, it is an easy stop with lively happy hour energy. The kitchen leans classic with a coastal bent—think chowder, cod, and a raw bar—punctuated by light global touches like yuzu and chimichurri. Execution shines on the raw side and steady favorites, though some cooked dishes skew salty or heavy. Come for the raw bar and reliable staples, manage expectations on more elaborate plates. Families can do well here thanks to fries, burgers, and tacos, though the focus is seafood. For cautious eaters, stick to simpler items like the burger, chowder, and fries. There is no kids menu, but several approachable choices make it reasonably kid-friendly if your crew is flexible.
At a Glance
- Outstanding happy hour value for oysters and snacks
- Attentive, friendly service with helpful recommendations
- Mixed execution on some hot dishes and seasoning
- Occasional long waits at peak times
- A few raw-seafood illness claims over time; exercise caution if sensitive
What Sets It Apart
- robust_happy_hour
- highline_proximity
- complimentary_mini_dessert
What People Love
- Feeling taken care of by engaged servers
- Fresh, briny oysters that taste of the sea
- A cozy, nautical vibe in the heart of Chelsea
- That little complimentary dessert touch at the end
- Happy hour that actually feels like a deal
Points of Concern
- Some mains run salty or bland; tacos and tataki draw mixed reactions
- Peak-time delays with long gaps between courses reported
- Size/value complaints about the lobster roll at $39
- Isolated billing issues reported by a few parties; verify receipts
- A handful of food poisoning claims tied to oysters despite many positive raw bar reviews
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$58-$78 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Build a raw bar flight (3-5 oysters, tuna tartare), share chowder, split cioppino; or do happy hour minis plus a single entree to finish.
Perfect For
- After-work oyster run near the High Line
- Casual date with cocktails and a raw bar platter
- Group meetups that appreciate lively energy
- Solo bar dining with quick happy hour bites
Location Insights
Area: Lively Chelsea corridor near the High Line and galleries; draws after-work crowds and weekend strollers.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked with tourists and locals; occasional congestion near attractions.
Nearby: Steps from the High Line, close to Chelsea Market and Meatpacking nightlife; strong bar and dining cluster.
ChelseaChelsea offers a lively dining environment with a mix of upscale restaurants, trendy bars, and casual eateries. The area is popular for its art scene and nightlife, drawing a crowd that appreciates both innovative cuisine and social atmosphere. It is generally safe and highly accessible, with a strong emphasis on contemporary and international dining options.
West ChelseaWest Chelsea, particularly near 10th Avenue, is known for its concentration of art galleries and the High Line park. The dining scene here is sophisticated, catering to visitors and residents who enjoy modern American and international fare in stylish settings.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday16:30–21:30
Tuesday16:30–21:30
Wednesday16:30–21:30
Thursday16:30–21:30
Friday16:30–22:00
Saturday12:00–22:00
Sunday12:00–21:00
Available: Reservations, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →