Takeout
Historic Village coffee roaster with outstanding bean selection and solid espresso, but customer service can be brusque and brewed drinks vary; best for buying beans and gifts over lingering.
Porto Rico Importing Co. delivers solid specialty coffee with strong espresso and drip offerings that earn loyal patronage, but inconsistent drink execution and variable service politeness prevent a higher grade. The historic Village setting and exceptional bean selection make it a worthwhile destination for coffee enthusiasts seeking quality origins and blends, though the tight space and no-seating format limit broader appeal.
Step inside and the air is thick with roasted-coffee aroma and old New York charm, a compact room lined with bags of beans and tea tins. Service feels counter-driven and brisk; one visitor noted, "I ordered at the back bar and sipped on the bench outside." However, expect a mix of warmth and brusqueness—some guides are helpful, others less so—so go in with specific questions ready. The culinary approach leans classic espresso and beans rather than novelty drinks. Regulars praise the cappuccino and drip for straight-ahead flavor, while a few lattes and mochas can skew weak or bitter if the bar is slammed. This is a roaster-retail hybrid: best-in-class for buying beans, spices, and sweets, with the coffee bar as a solid complement rather than the main act—ideal if you love choosing origins and blends. Families will find quick grab-and-go convenience and sweets like chocolate croissants and dark chocolate cherries, but there is no real seating and space is tight. Kids who enjoy hot chocolate–style mochas may like it, though picky drinkers might prefer simpler milk-and-espresso options. Strollers may feel cramped during rush hours.
Area: Quintessential Village block with independent shops; draws coffee enthusiasts, locals, and visitors.
Safety: Generally safe, heavy foot traffic day and evening; typical urban vigilance advised.
Nearby: Near NYU, boutique retail, other cafes; strong daytime pedestrian flow and tourist presence.
Available: Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →