Seemor
Milly's PizzeriaBWorth Trying
834 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11206
· Pizza restaurant, Italian restaurant, Pizza delivery
· 4.4/5 Google (265 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Neighborhood slice shop with standout Sicilian and Grandma pies, fast service, and budget pricing; occasional inconsistency and rare safety complaints mean stick to pizza over creamy pastas.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Milly's Pizzeria delivers solid neighborhood pizza execution with strong food quality in its core offering—Sicilian and Grandma slices earn consistent praise for crisp crust and balanced sauce. Friendly, fast counter service and budget-friendly pricing make it a reliable casual stop, though occasional inconsistency in doneness and toppings and limited non-pizza reliability prevent a higher grade. Best experienced for what it is: a quick, affordable slice destination rather than a destination pizzeria.
Restaurant Summary
A compact neighborhood slice joint where the trays of squares catch your eye and the counter crew keeps things moving. Diners rave about the Sicilian and Grandma pies, calling out a crisp crust and balanced sauce. One guest put it simply: "The white slice had me planning a return trip." Service feels friendly and fast, though it can get lively at peak hours. The cooking sticks to classic New York pizza with a few old-school Italian comforts. When you aim for pizza, you generally win here; a handful of reviews suggest pastas like Alfredo can be hit or miss, so most folks lean on the pies and slices. Prices are wallet-friendly for the area, making it easy to grab a couple of slices or a whole pie without planning a splurge. For families, this is easy going: slices, garlic knots, chicken fingers, and simple pastas mean most kids will find something familiar. There is no special kids menu, but the straightforward options and quick counter flow make it a low-stress stop with takeout as a reliable backup.
At a Glance
- Sicilian and Grandma pies frequently praised for flavor and texture
- Fast, friendly counter service with budget pricing
- Occasional inconsistency (over/undercooked, sparse toppings) reported
- Isolated food safety complaints; safest bets are pizza items
- Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food
What Sets It Apart
- standout_sicilian_and_grandma
- fast_counter_service
- budget_whole_pies
What People Love
- Thick, airy Sicilian squares
- Crisp Grandma pie with savory sauce
- Friendly counter team that moves fast
- Great value for whole pies and slices
Points of Concern
- Isolated food safety complaints tied to pizza and Alfredo; proceed with caution on creamy pastas
- Delivery can be slow during rush and has order minimums
- Inconsistency on doneness and topping coverage pops up occasionally
- Review patterns show signs of potential manipulation (some templated owner replies and generic superlatives) which may not reflect typical diner experience
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$18-26 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Lean into pizza-focused items (Grandma, Sicilian, White) for best results at $19-25
- Use salads and fries for vegetarian and lighter options
- Heros at $10-11 offer hearty value if you are skipping pizza
Perfect For
- Quick slice before or after nearby bars
- Casual takeout night with a whole pie
- Solo lunch on the go
- Family dinner when you need kid-friendly options fast
Location Insights
Area: Lively mixed-commercial stretch with locals, commuters, and late-night foot traffic near transit.
Safety: Generally active and fine, with occasional rowdy behavior reported inside once.
Nearby: Close to bars, shops, and residential blocks; convenient for quick slices and takeout.
East WilliamsburgEast Williamsburg offers a dynamic dining scene with a blend of casual eateries, artisanal cafes, and innovative restaurants. The neighborhood maintains a gritty, industrial charm while evolving into a trendy destination, attracting a mix of creatives and locals seeking authentic and eclectic food experiences.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–23:00
Tuesday11:00–23:00
Wednesday11:00–23:00
Thursday11:00–23:00
Friday11:00–23:00
Saturday11:00–23:00
Sunday11:00–23:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →