Seemor
The AbbeyA-Worth Trying
65 S Clerk St, Edinburgh EH8 9PP
· Pub, Restaurant
· 4.6/5 Google (1825 reviews)
Reservations · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Cozy Newington pub with hearty Scottish comfort food, standout whisky flights, and friendly service; expect classic dishes over culinary fireworks at fair city prices.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
The Abbey delivers solid Scottish pub cooking with generous portions and exceptional whisky expertise that elevates the experience beyond typical neighborhood fare. Reliable execution and friendly service make it a dependable local favorite, though occasional starter inconsistencies and peak-time crowding prevent grade A territory. Fair pricing and loyal repeat visits confirm its standing as a respected Edinburgh pub destination.
Restaurant Summary
A neighborhood fixture in Newington, The Abbey feels like a cozy local pub that just happens to pour serious whisky. The room is warm and wood-lined, the back bar lined with drams that regulars love to explore. Service is often praised as friendly and helpful, with staff guiding whisky flights and squeezing in last-minute tables. One diner summed it up: "It became our place to end the day—good food, a welcoming vibe, and a dram to match." The cooking leans classic Scottish pub fare with hearty portions rather than fancy flourishes. Think fish and chips, steak and ale pie, haggis with whisky sauce, and a surprisingly excellent lambs liver. The culinary approach is traditional and comforting: reliable pub classics cooked with care, plus a deep whisky program that rewards curiosity. Families do well here. The menu has plenty kids will actually eat—mac and cheese, chicken strips, burgers, fish and chips, and breakfast pancakes—backed by a warm, casual atmosphere. While peak evenings can be noisy and Sunday roast fills quickly, most visits feel easy with staff used to groups and travelers. If you need quieter space for little ones, aim for lunch or breakfast when it is calmer.
At a Glance
- Traditional Scottish comfort food with generous portions
- Excellent whisky selection and knowledgeable guidance
- Fair prices for the area; good value on mains and desserts
- Peak-time waits and occasional service impatience
- Quality dips on a few starters and cocktail execution
What Sets It Apart
- extensive_whisky_flights
- traditional_scottish_menu
- hearty_breakfasts
What People Love
- Hearty classics that hit the spot
- Staff who help build a whisky flight you will enjoy
- Desserts like sticky toffee pudding that end the night right
- A relaxed, local feel away from heavy tourist zones
Points of Concern
- Service can feel impatient on very busy nights or holidays (isolated mentions)
- Inconsistency on a few items like chicken strips or chips texture
- Noise and crowding at peak times; breakfast is calmer
- Occasional booking confusion (reported 'fully booked' despite empty room in one case)
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost£26-36 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- For vegetarians: Mac & Cheese (£11.95) or Veggie Haggis / Haggis Bon Bons; Halloumi Wrap for a lighter option
- For vegans: Vegan Salad (vg)(gf) and Vegan Abbey Breakfast; Moving Mountain Burger without cheese
- For budget-friendly comfort: Lambs Liver (£11.95) or Haggis (£12.00) with whisky sauce add-on
Perfect For
- A casual Scottish pub dinner with drams
- Sunday roast with friends
- Easygoing family meal in Newington
- Whisky flights for curious beginners
Location Insights
Area: Student-heavy, residential-meets-commercial corridor near the University of Edinburgh; casual local vibe with steady foot traffic.
Safety: Generally safe and well-traveled, especially evenings; standard city awareness advised late night.
Nearby: Close to university buildings, Commonwealth Pool, and independent shops; away from the heaviest Royal Mile crowds.
SouthsideSouthside is a lively and diverse neighborhood featuring a mix of affordable eateries, traditional pubs, and trendy cafes. It has a strong student presence due to nearby university campuses, contributing to a dynamic dining scene that balances casual and eclectic options.
MarchmontMarchmont is a sub-area within Southside known for its residential streets filled with tenement flats and a strong student community. The dining environment here includes budget-friendly cafes, takeaway spots, and some independent restaurants catering to a youthful crowd.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday10:00–00:00
Tuesday10:00–00:00
Wednesday10:00–00:00
Thursday10:00–00:00
Friday09:30–01:00
Saturday09:00–00:00
Sunday09:00–00:00
Available: Reservations, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →