Seemor
Simply Natural Grill HouseB+Worth Trying
217 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211
· Jamaican restaurant
· 5/5 Google (148 reviews)
Takeout
Smoky, flavor-packed Jamaican platters from a friendly sidewalk grill; generous portions and great lunch special, with occasional inconsistency on rice and pork texture.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Simply Natural Grill House delivers excellent food quality anchored by authentic jerk chicken and tender oxtail that justify its loyal following. Warm, attentive service and appealing street-side atmosphere elevate the experience, though occasional consistency variability and the inherent limitations of sidewalk service prevent a higher grade. For casual Caribbean street food, this represents solid neighborhood-level execution.
Restaurant Summary
Grill smoke curls over the sidewalk and the music sets a laid-back rhythm; plates arrive heavy with rice, plantains, and shimmering jerk glaze. A diner put it best: "The chicken had crisp skin and juicy heat." Service feels warm and upbeat, with staff chatting through sauces and spice levels. Expect a lively curbside scene where the aroma does most of the advertising. The cooking is classic Jamaican street fare rather than chef-y mashups: tender oxtail, proper jerk chicken, curry goat, and island sides. The culinary approach leans traditional and smoke-driven (innovation level 4.2): technique over theatrics, with heat adjustable through house sauces like mango and smoked chile. Portions run generous, and the lunch special deal is a repeat-diner magnet. For families, the menu offers kid-friendly entry points: mild jerk, coconut rice, mac and cheese, and sweet plantains. There is no kids menu, but simple sides and milder sauces make it workable. Street setup means casual, quick meals over long sit-downs; bring napkins and embrace the vibe.
At a Glance
- Smoky, authentic jerk and ultra-tender oxtail
- Generous portions and strong lunch special value
- Friendly, enthusiastic service with helpful sauce guidance
- Occasional dry jerk pork or undercooked rice reports
- Limited seating; sidewalk pickup can mean short waits
What Sets It Apart
- barrel_grill_aroma
- sauce_flight_customization
- hearty_lunch_special
What People Love
- Deep jerk smoke and balanced heat
- Fall-off-the-bone oxtail richness
- Hearty platters that feel like a feast
- Upbeat staff energy and island tunes
- Value-forward lunch special
Points of Concern
- Isolated complaints about dry jerk pork texture
- A few mentions of undercooked rice and peas
- Street setup has limited or no seating, so plan to walk or eat nearby
- Pricing for premium cuts (oxtail) can feel high to some given street setting
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$22-35 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Pair jerk chicken ($14.99 mid) with mango sauce for balanced heat
- Add baked mac & cheese ($7.99) for a richer plate
- Choose coconut rice on spicy days for contrast
Perfect For
- A quick, flavor-packed lunch break
- Casual takeout with friends in the neighborhood
- Comforting island cravings without a long sit-down
- Spice lovers who want adjustable heat via sauces
Location Insights
Area: Trendy, youthful Williamsburg corridor with strong foot traffic and casual street-food energy.
Safety: Well-trafficked retail blocks; generally safe with good daytime and evening footfall.
Nearby: Boutiques, cafes, bars; pop-ups also noted around NoHo/SoHo near NYU and Broadway.
WilliamsburgWilliamsburg is characterized by a lively dining scene featuring trendy cafes, artisanal eateries, and innovative restaurants. The social atmosphere is energetic and eclectic, with a strong emphasis on creativity and cultural events. The area is generally safe and highly accessible by public transit.
North WilliamsburgNorth Williamsburg, where Bedford Avenue is located, is known for its bustling commercial strip with a mix of vintage shops, bars, and diverse dining venues. It has a youthful vibe and is a hotspot for weekend socializing and nightlife.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–17:30
Tuesday11:00–17:30
Wednesday11:00–17:30
Thursday11:00–17:30
Friday11:00–17:30
Saturday
Sunday
Available: Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →