Seemor
Two BrothersBWorth Trying
896 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11206
· Jamaican restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (132 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Lively, affordable Jamaican spot with standout oxtail, curry goat, and jerk chicken; big portions and bold flavors, but service consistency and occasional food safety/cleanliness complaints warrant caution.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Two Brothers delivers solid neighborhood dining anchored by strong food quality—oxtail and curry goat earn genuine devotion—and exceptional value for money. However, inconsistent execution (tender versus tough oxtail, variable plantain quality) and occasional food safety reports prevent a higher grade. This is a worth-trying casual spot for hearty Jamaican comfort at friendly prices, best suited for diners who prioritize generous portions and authentic flavor over consistency guarantees.
Restaurant Summary
Two Brothers feels like a neighborhood staple where the grill smoke and reggae set a warm and bustling tone. Guests talk about trays packed to the brim and staff who can be genuinely kind when the line is moving. One diner raved, "The oxtail and curry goat were worth the detour," though others warn that lunch rush can be a bit of a wait. The cooking leans classic Jamaican comfort: tender oxtail when it is on, assertive curry goat with extra gravy, and jerk chicken that some love while others find too tame or charred. Expect big, satisfying portions over fancy plating, a better fit for hearty appetites than for food trend-chasing. If you are after dependable neighborhood flavor at friendly prices, this checks the box—just know quality can swing by time of day. For families, the menu has several kid-friendly staples like fried chicken, mac and cheese, patties, rice, and sweet plantains. Adventurous kids might enjoy jerk chicken, but spice levels and occasional dryness of plantains vary. No explicit kids menu, yet there are enough simple choices to keep younger diners happy.
At a Glance
- Big portions and strong value for money
- Oxtail, curry goat, and mac and cheese are consistent crowd-pleasers
- Service attitude and phone ordering can be inconsistent
- Occasional cleanliness and food safety complaints over time
- Jerk chicken seasoning and char level vary widely
What Sets It Apart
- late_night_hours
- big_portion_value
- neighborhood_hidden_gem_vibe
What People Love
- Hearty, saucy oxtail over rice and peas
- Curry goat with extra gravy poured over everything
- Mac and cheese that rounds out the plate
- Neighborhood vibe with music and friendly moments
Points of Concern
- Service can feel curt or disorganized during rush; phone orders may be put on long hold
- Variable consistency: tough oxtail or dry plantains reported on off-days
- A few cleanliness and food safety complaints across years—rare but notable
- Parking is difficult on Broadway; expect to walk a bit
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$22-$35 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Build a combo: Jerk Chicken ($9+) or Curry Goat ($11+) with Rice and Peas ($4+) and Mac and Cheese ($5.50).
- Quick budget bite: Jerk Patty with Coco Bread ($5).
- Seafood fans: Sweet Chili Salmon ($17) or Fried Fish meal ($10+).
Perfect For
- Casual weeknight takeout when you want hearty portions
- Late-night bite after a show or bar nearby
- Comfort food cravings for Caribbean classics
- Solo quick meal at the counter
Location Insights
Area: Busy Broadway corridor on Bed-Stuy/Bushwick line with nightlife, bars, and foot traffic; casual, late-night crowd.
Safety: Generally active and well-trafficked; typical urban awareness needed late at night.
Nearby: Near Cafe Erzulie and Myrtle-Broadway transit; mix of bars, small shops, and residential blocks.
BushwickBushwick has transformed into a vibrant dining and nightlife destination with a strong presence of trendy cafes, art galleries, and innovative restaurants alongside longstanding local establishments. The social atmosphere is eclectic and energetic, attracting a diverse crowd interested in contemporary culture and affordable urban living.
East BushwickEast Bushwick retains more of its industrial roots with warehouses and manufacturing spaces, but is increasingly seeing creative repurposing and new dining spots that cater to adventurous eaters and locals seeking authentic, less commercialized experiences.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday09:00–22:00
Tuesday09:00–22:00
Wednesday09:00–22:00
Thursday09:00–22:00
Friday09:00–22:00
Saturday09:00–05:00
Sunday
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →