Takeout · Outdoor seating
Lively downtown pub serving crowd-pleasing comfort food, strong pours, and friendly service at fair prices for Ketchum, though it gets loud and weekend waits can stretch.
The Cellar Pub delivers solid A-grade performance through strong food quality anchored by standout fish and chips and elevated comfort dishes, paired with reliable friendly service and quick execution. The underground cellar setting offers charm and warmth, though crowding on weekends and modest design sophistication prevent grade A territory. Fair pricing and consistent execution across dimensions make this a competitive neighborhood favorite in Ketchum.
Down a set of stairs in downtown Ketchum, this cellar hangout feels warm and bustling the moment you step inside. Reviewers talk about “stiff pours,” friendly bartenders, and food that lands well above typical bar fare. It can be loud on weekends, but that buzz is part of the charm; patio seats, when available, provide a calmer counterpoint. Expect fast service on weekdays and more of a crush during peak hours. The kitchen focuses on pub comfort with a few elevated touches—think fish and chips with dill tartar, proper bangers and mash, and a flat iron steak salad that wins over skeptics. The culinary approach leans classic and satisfying: elevated traditional rather than chef showmanship. Cocktails trend simple and strong; some guests find prices high for non-craft builds, while the food is widely considered a good value for Ketchum. Families fare well earlier in the day thanks to kid-friendly staples like chicken strips, burgers, fries, and a hand-dipped corn dog. If you have selective eaters, the menu’s familiar options make this an easy pick, though those with gluten-free or dairy-free needs may find limited flexibility. For quieter conversation, try weekday dinners or the outdoor seating when weather allows.
Area: Resort-town core with active apres-ski and year-round tourism; mix of locals and visitors seeking casual eats and drinks.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked downtown with nightlife; busy on weekends.
Nearby: Steps from other bars, restaurants, and shops; convenient for bar-hopping and casual meals before/after outdoor activities.
Available: Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →