Seemor
Salvatore'sBWorth Trying
16 Roseneath St, Edinburgh EH9 1JH
· Fish and chips takeaway
· 4.7/5 Google (324 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Beloved neighborhood chippy-pizzeria delivering crisp haddock, crowd-pleasing pizzas, and warm family-run vibes at budget prices, with occasional portion and service hiccups.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Salvatore's earns a grade B through strong food quality and friendly, attentive service, anchored by exceptional value and a devoted local following spanning decades. However, inconsistent execution during peak times—occasional soggy batter and light portions—prevents higher grades, while the functional but modest setting keeps it neighborhood-focused rather than destination-worthy. A reliable neighborhood gem that delivers what it promises most nights.
Restaurant Summary
On a quiet Marchmont corner, Salvatore's feels like a warm neighborhood hub where regulars swap hellos and travelers duck in from the Meadows for something crisp and comforting. The counter hums, fryers sing, and more than a few reviews mention the owners by name with lines like, "They made us feel right at home". There is no polish-for-show here, just straightforward good cooking and prices that keep locals coming back. The cooking leans classic British chippy with an Italian accent—stone-baked pizzas alongside crisp haddock, battered sausages, and haggis. The culinary approach is traditional and crowd-pleasing: fresh frying, light batter when they are on their game, and simple, satisfying pizzas that punch above their price. Most nights deliver exactly what you want from a chippy, though a few diners hit soggy batter or small chip portions during rushes. Families fit right in. Kids gravitate to Margherita slices and nuggets, and chips are dependable comfort. There is no formal kids menu, but the lineup is naturally child-friendly—plain pizzas, sausages, and simple sides. If you need gluten-free or vegan mains, choices are limited, so plan accordingly.
At a Glance
- Crisp, fresh-tasting haddock and standout value for money
- Stone-baked pizzas win praise from locals and visitors
- Friendly, family-run service with loyal regulars over decades
- Portions, especially chips, can feel light for some orders
- Occasional quality dips (soggy batter, watery sides) at busy times
What Sets It Apart
- family_run_warmth
- dual_focus_chippy_and_pizza
- signature_house_sauce
What People Love
- The crackle of light batter around flaky haddock
- Friendly chats with the owners while waiting
- Pizza that tastes freshly made, not factory
- Prices that make repeat visits easy
Points of Concern
- Portion size disputes appear occasionally, especially around chips and half suppers
- A few reports of soggy batter or dry fish during rushes
- One-off complaints about curt service from a younger staff member
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost£12-18 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- For kids or picky eaters: Plain or Margherita pizza (£5.50-£6.50 small), chicken nuggets supper (£5.90 lunch), chips
- Best value mains: Haddock supper (£7.90-£11.40), Diavola/Pepperoni pizza (£6.50-£14.00)
- Vegetarian picks: Ortolana or Funghi pizzas; vegetable burger supper
Perfect For
- An affordable comfort-food dinner after a Meadows stroll
- A quick family takeaway where everyone finds something simple
- Students on a budget craving classic fish and chips
- Locals who want reliable pizza without the price tag
Location Insights
Area: Leafy student-heavy residential area near the Meadows with a local, down-to-earth vibe.
Safety: Generally safe, busy with students and families; typical city awareness advised at night.
Nearby: Close to the Meadows, university housing, cafes, and small shops; steady takeaway footfall.
MarchmontMarchmont is a popular residential area characterized by its Victorian tenements and proximity to the University of Edinburgh. The dining scene is diverse, featuring casual cafes, traditional pubs, and international eateries that cater to a youthful and academic crowd. The atmosphere is relaxed yet lively, with a strong community feel and good accessibility to the city center.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:30–13:30, 16:30–23:30
Tuesday11:30–13:30, 16:30–23:30
Wednesday11:30–13:30, 16:30–23:30
Thursday11:30–13:30, 14:30–00:00
Friday11:30–13:30, 16:30–00:00
Saturday16:30–00:00
Sunday
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →