Seemor

Fellini's PizzaB

1991 Howell Mill Rd NW, Atlanta, GA 30318 · Pizza restaurant, Restaurant

A dependable, late-night New York-style pizza stop with big slices, strong value, and a laid-back vibe — but ordering mistakes, occasional service lapses, and inconsistency keep it from being a slam dunk.

Why this grade

Fellini's Pizza delivers dependable neighborhood pizza with solid food quality and strong value, earning its grade B standing. However, inconsistent execution — including order mistakes and occasional quality lapses — and uneven service attentiveness prevent it from reaching higher territory. It's a reliable casual stop for straightforward New York-style slices and pies, best suited for relaxed meals rather than special occasions.

The full picture

Fellini’s Pizza feels like the sort of place Atlanta keeps in its back pocket: loud enough to have personality, casual enough to drop in after a concert, and dependable enough that longtime regulars keep circling back. Reviewers keep coming back to the same strengths — crisp New York-style slices, big portions, and a no-fuss vibe — with one fan calling it a spot where you can “relax and create your own pizza,” while another loved the “two slices and a drink” deal that’s hard to beat. The culinary approach is classic pizza-shop comfort rather than culinary fireworks. Expect thin, crispy slices, Sicilian pies, calzones, and a small but useful set of veggie and salad options. The best orders seem to be the straightforward ones: plain cheese, the Special, white pizza, spinach-mushroom, and Sicilian pies. It’s a strong fit for people who want familiar, fast, satisfying pizza; less so for diners chasing creativity or a wide menu. If you want adventurous food, this is not that place — but if you want a hot slice that tastes like it should, it mostly delivers. For families, it’s broadly workable: there are familiar cheese, pepperoni, veggie, white pizza, calzone, and salad options that kids can actually eat, and one review specifically noted a picky child liked the plain slice. That said, this is still a pizza-first room with occasional loud music and a few service hiccups, so it’s better for relaxed family meals than quiet celebrations. If your kids are picky, stick to the regular cheese, pepperoni, or plain slice; the more loaded pies are better left to pizza enthusiasts.

What to order here

What stands out

A few notes

Seemor's grade is our automated opinion of what public reviews say, analyzed July 2026, not a first-hand review of the restaurant. The notes summarize what reviewers report. How we grade · Report a correction

Location Insights

Area vibe: Trendy, rapidly redeveloping corridor with a mix of industrial heritage and new bars and restaurants.

Safety: Generally safe with active evening foot traffic near dining spots; some quieter pockets after hours.

What's nearby: Near West Midtown arts, tech offices, the Atlanta BeltLine (northern spur plans), and cluster of restaurants and warehouses converted to venues.

Opening Hours

Monday11:00–00:00 Tuesday11:00–00:00 Wednesday11:00–00:00 Thursday11:00–00:00 Friday11:00–00:00 Saturday11:00–00:00 Sunday11:00–00:00
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →