A spacious, lively Auburn pizzeria with consistently popular, generously topped pies, strong family appeal, and occasional complaints about parking, quality variation, and slow or inaccurate service.
Old Town Pizza delivers solid food quality anchored by praise for flavorful crust and fresh toppings, paired with warm and efficient service that keeps diners satisfied. The spacious, bright setting with sports screens and outdoor seating creates genuine appeal for a casual Auburn outing. Consistency remains good but not flawless, particularly on heavily topped or takeout orders, which prevents a stronger showing.
Old Town Pizza is a spacious, lively Auburn institution that feels built for groups: bright open dining rooms, sports screens, a full bar, upstairs outdoor seating, and enough room to absorb a crowd. Regulars describe it as their dependable pizza-night destination, with one memorable takeaway being a venue that is “much bigger inside than expected.” Parking is the recurring practical snag, so the experience starts more smoothly if you arrive early or reserve. The cooking is classic, generous Italian-American pizzeria fare rather than a precision-driven destination kitchen. Thin-crust pizzas arrive with abundant toppings, and the Caboose, Choo Choo Chicken, Veggie Train, Royal Hawaiian, calzones, wings, and cheesy breadsticks earn repeated praise. Reviews are overwhelmingly enthusiastic, though a few diners report tough crust, uneven topping quality, or disappointing takeout, suggesting occasional execution swings. Lunch specials and shareable portions make the pricing reasonable for families and groups, while drinks and very large specialty pies can push the bill higher. Families are especially well served: the menu includes familiar pizza, chicken strips, sliders, hot dog wrap, sandwiches, ice cream, gelato, and dessert pizza, while reviews mention children enjoying the elevator, outdoor seating, and welcoming hosts. Gluten-free cauliflower crust and several vegetarian choices broaden the appeal. It is a strong choice for family outings, though picky eaters may prefer a simply topped pizza because heavily loaded pies can be less evenly cooked.
Area vibe: Historic downtown with a small-town, tourism-focused vibe and visible old-town architecture.
Safety: Generally safe daytime and early evening; quieter at night so exercise normal caution after dark.
What's nearby: Located on Auburn's High Street near Gold Rush landmarks, shops, cafes, and municipal buildings; close to Hwy 49 and I-80 access.