Seemor
IT Italian TrattoriaC+Worth Trying
530 7th Ave, New York, NY 10018
· Italian restaurant, Coffee shop, Fast food restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (2120 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Casual Italian in the Garment District with counter ordering, solid pizzas and simple pastas, but inconsistent execution, crowding, and small portions; good for a quick bite near Times Square if expectations are set.
Why it gets a C+ for overall quality
IT Italian Trattoria delivers occasional highlights—truffle pizza and friendly staff earn genuine praise—but inconsistent execution undermines reliability, with reports of cold pasta, undersauced dishes, and variable service pacing. Tight seating and crowding during rushes, combined with hygiene concerns, prevent a higher grade despite the convenient midtown location. Best suited for quick coffee runs or simple pizza orders rather than full meals.
Restaurant Summary
A casual spot near Times Square where the room feels warm and bustling, with counter ordering and plates delivered to your table. Reviewers praise friendly staff and quick coffee service, though some cite crowding and uneven cleanup. One diner raved, "the truffle pizza hit the spot," while another found the pasta underwhelming. The cooking leans classic Italian with a few truffle-forward detours—think Margherita, Bolognese, Carbonara, and tiramisu in multiple flavors. Execution is mixed: several call the pizzas flavorful and pastas fresh, while others report lukewarm lasagna or dry, undersauced rigatoni. Best results seem to come from simpler choices and the truffle selections. Families do fine here because there are kid-friendly staples like Margherita pizza, plain pomodoro, and croissants. There is no kids menu, but the menu has simple options most children will eat. Space is tight during rushes, so strollers and large groups may find it cramped.
At a Glance
- Convenient midtown location near Penn Station and Times Square
- Truffle pizza and tiramisu flavors draw frequent praise
- Inconsistent pasta execution (cold, bland, undersauced reports)
- Tight, crowded seating and slow table clearing at peak
- Counter service—order at the register; manage expectations on service pace
What Sets It Apart
- truffle_specialties
- broad_tiramisu_flavors
- central_midtown_location
What People Love
- Truffle-forward pizzas with rich flavor
- Multiple tiramisu and cannoli options
- Friendly greetings and welcoming vibe
- Cozy decor amid the Midtown bustle
Points of Concern
- Pasta consistency varies; several reports of cold or bland dishes
- Portions can feel small and light on sauce
- Crowded room with slow bussing during rushes
- Restroom and cleanliness complaints appear occasionally
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$36-48 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Choose Margherita or Truffle Positano pizzas for best value
- For pasta, opt for Pomodoro or Pesto; avoid Carbonara if you prefer traditional guanciale style
Perfect For
- Quick pre-show pizza or pasta near Times Square
- Casual lunch between meetings in Midtown
- Coffee and pastry pit stop with seating
- Families seeking easy Italian staples
Location Insights
Area: Busy midtown Garment District near Times Square; heavy foot traffic, office workers, and tourists.
Safety: Generally safe, high pedestrian volume, bright at night; occasional crowding discomfort.
Nearby: Near Penn Station, Times Square, offices, hotels; convenient for commuters and visitors.
Garment DistrictThe Garment District is a vibrant area with a mix of wholesale fashion businesses, trendy eateries, and casual dining spots. It attracts a diverse crowd including local workers on lunch breaks, tourists visiting nearby attractions, and creatives from the fashion industry, creating a dynamic and fast-paced dining atmosphere.
nullnull
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday07:00–00:00
Tuesday07:00–00:00
Wednesday07:00–00:00
Thursday07:00–00:00
Friday07:00–00:00
Saturday07:00–00:00
Sunday07:00–00:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →