Seemor

Westside PizzaB-Worth Trying

Name: Westside Pizza
Address: 323 High School Rd NE, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110, Bainbridge Island, United States
Rating: 4.4

323 High School Rd NE, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110 · Pizza restaurant, Caterer, Chicken wings restaurant · 4.4/5 Google (533 reviews)

Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Solid, family-friendly pizza joint with approachable prices and a welcoming vibe, but expect occasional service hiccups and a lively, sometimes noisy atmosphere.

Why it gets a B- for overall quality

Westside Pizza delivers solid neighborhood dining with reliable pizza quality and exceptional family appeal through arcade entertainment and welcoming staff. However, inconsistent execution with variable topping amounts and occasional quality lapses alongside uneven service during peak times prevent a higher grade. Strong local loyalty and fair value make it a worthwhile visit for casual, family-oriented dining rather than a destination establishment.

Restaurant Summary

Westside Pizza is the kind of place where families, locals, and visitors all find common ground over a hot, cheesy slice. The vibe is casual and lively, with arcade games and pinball machines providing entertainment for kids and a steady hum of conversation from regulars and newcomers alike. The staff is often praised for their friendliness, and the owner is notably responsive to feedback, both online and in person. While the pizza is the star—described as 'delicious and filling' by many—there are also solid options for salads and wings, though the latter receives mixed reviews. Culinarily, Westside Pizza sticks to classic, crowd-pleasing recipes rather than pushing boundaries. Expect familiar toppings, generous portions, and the ability to build your own pie to suit any taste. This is not the spot for avant-garde foodies seeking fusion or experimental flavors, but rather for those who appreciate a well-executed traditional pizza in a welcoming setting. The menu includes vegetarian and gluten-free options, and the pricing is approachable, with specials like two slices and a drink for $8 making it a solid value for the area. For families with kids, Westside Pizza is a standout choice. Multiple reviews highlight how children are entertained by the arcade games and how even picky eaters find something to love. The menu features simple, familiar pizzas and salads, and the staff is accommodating to custom orders. If you're looking for a quiet, romantic dinner, this may not be your scene—expect a lively, sometimes noisy atmosphere, especially during birthday parties or game nights. But for a fun, relaxed meal with the whole family, it's hard to beat.

At a Glance

Exceptionally family-friendly with arcade games and group seating.
Good value for the area, especially with slice specials and generous portions.
Strong local following and community support.
Service speed and order accuracy can be inconsistent during busy times.
Wings receive mixed reviews; stick to pizza and salads for best experience.

What Sets It Apart

arcade_games
community_support
slice_specials

What People Love

The arcade games and pinball machines that keep kids entertained
Friendly, welcoming staff who remember regulars
Generous portions and filling slice specials
Community involvement and support for local events
The ability to customize pizzas for picky eaters

Points of Concern

Service can be slow or orders lost during peak times; patience may be required.
Some inconsistency in topping amounts and food temperature, especially on large orders.
Wings are frequently criticized for texture and preparation—best to avoid.
Noise levels can be high during parties or busy hours, making conversation challenging.

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleCounter With Seating Average Cost$18-25 per person ReservationsNot required

What to Order

Opt for the slice specials for best value.
Try the Veggie Pizza or Greek Salad for lighter, fresh options.
Customize your pizza to suit dietary needs—staff is accommodating.

Perfect For

A family pizza night with kids who need entertainment
Casual group outings after a movie or sports event
Birthday parties or team celebrations
Solo lunch breaks with a quick slice and relaxed vibe

Location Insights

Area: Casual, family-oriented downtown area with a mix of local businesses and entertainment venues; popular with both residents and visitors.

Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, and walkable; no significant safety concerns reported in reviews.

Nearby: Located near the Ruby movie theater and ferry terminal; surrounded by other casual dining spots and retail shops.

Bainbridge IslandAn upscale, predominantly residential island community with a sophisticated dining scene featuring farm-to-table restaurants, local wineries, and independent cafes that reflect the area's progressive, environmentally conscious culture.

WinslowThe primary commercial district of Bainbridge Island, characterized by walkable streets, boutique shops, and a vibrant local dining scene that emphasizes community and quality local ingredients.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday11:00–20:00 Tuesday11:00–20:00 Wednesday11:00–20:00 Thursday11:00–20:00 Friday11:00–21:00 Saturday11:00–21:00 Sunday11:00–20:00

Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →