Name: Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering
Address: 122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706, Bay Shore, United States

Question 1

Is Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering in Bay Shore good?

Accepted Answer

Seemor grades Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering a B for overall quality. A long-established waterfront seafood restaurant with attractive marina views, broad appeal, and strong event service, but uneven execution and several serious service and food-quality complaints make timing and occasion matter. Full Restaurant DNA analysis is available on seemor.ai.

Question 2

What kind of food does Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering serve?

Accepted Answer

Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering in Bay Shore serves Waterfront seafood restaurant.

Question 3

What should I order at Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering?

Accepted Answer

The menu’s best bets range from baked stuffed clams and crab cakes to cedar-planked salmon, swordfish, and surf and turf.

Question 4

What should I know before going to Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering?

Accepted Answer

Plan for waterfront pricing and a polished occasion setting, but allow extra time because busy service can be inconsistent and parking policies may vary.

Question 5

What's Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering like?

Accepted Answer

Boats, sunsets, patio seating, and spacious event rooms create an occasion-ready waterfront atmosphere, with service that can vary when the restaurant is busy.

Captain Bills Restaurant & CateringB

Opening Hours

Captain Bills Restaurant & CateringB

Opening Hours

Nearby alternatives