Seemor

Red GarterB-?Proceed Cautiously

Name: Red Garter
Address: Via dei Benci, 33, R, 50122 Firenze FI, Italy, Firenze, Italy
Rating: 4.4

Via dei Benci, 33, R, 50122 Firenze FI, Italy · Bar, American restaurant, Steak house · 4.4/5 Google (4491 reviews)

Reservations · Delivery · Takeout

High-energy American sports bar and karaoke club in Santa Croce with solid burgers, lively nights, and some serious security and crowd-management complaints—great for fun groups, not ideal for a quiet meal.

Why it gets a B-? for overall quality

⚠️ Review concerns: This assessment reflects moderate uncertainty due to questionable review patterns. See details in Authenticity Assessment. Red Garter delivers solid execution as a sports-and-karaoke-first venue with strong burger and wing offerings and genuinely attentive table service. However, quality variation and occasional cold dishes combined with tight, crowded conditions at peak hours keep it from reaching higher territory. While there's moderate uncertainty due to review authenticity concerns, the grade reflects what most guests will encounter: a welcoming, energetic neighborhood spot better suited for group outings than quiet dining.

Restaurant Summary

Set just off Santa Croce, Red Garter feels raucous and welcoming from the moment you step in. Screens glow with live games, karaoke spills from the back room, and servers hustle with easy smiles. One guest remarked the team "set up our NFL game and saved us a table," capturing the sports-first camaraderie. However, there are some review authenticity concerns suggesting certain reviews may be solicited or influenced. The cooking sticks to classic American comfort: burgers in multiple sizes, wings by the dozen, ribs, and nachos. It is not chasing trends; it is the kind of menu that suits game nights, trivia, and loud singalongs more than white-tablecloth dining. Fans praise juicy burgers and speedy service, while a minority call out cold food and a rough delivery experience. Expect straightforward crowd-pleasers over culinary fireworks. For families, early evenings work best. Kids who like burgers and fries will find plenty, and Caesar or Greek salads offer simple alternatives. The late-night scene shifts toward DJ beats and karaoke with crowds and higher volume, so plan dinner early if bringing children and skip the club hours.

At a Glance

High-energy sports and karaoke hub with friendly table service
Solid burgers, wings, and ribs at fair central-city prices
Multiple reports of aggressive or arbitrary security behavior
Crowded, very loud at peak; long karaoke waits
Some review authenticity concerns and mixed safety reports late night

What Sets It Apart

dedicated_karaoke_hall
sports_broadcasts_in_multiple_zones
theme_nights_trivia_wings_tacos

What People Love

The buzz of karaoke and DJ nights
Servers who accommodate big tables and screen requests
Comforting burgers and wings that arrive fast
Theme nights like trivia, tacos, and wings

Points of Concern

Recurring complaints about bouncer conduct and inconsistent entry policies; impacts perceived safety late night
Crowd control issues: long karaoke lines, packed dance floor, and very loud music
A few hygiene and pest reports on delivery or late hours; isolated but serious
Review patterns show signs of potential manipulation (staff name repetition, templated praise) which may not reflect typical diner experience

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost€28-42 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

Pick mid-tier burger size (€14.90) for best value balance
Share Nachos Supreme (€11.50) plus 20 wings (€15.00) for groups
Dessert duo deal (€10.00 for two pieces) suits sharing after ribs

Perfect For

Watching big games with a group
Karaoke nights and birthday outings
Study-abroad meetups craving American bar food
Casual pre-game dinner before a late night

Location Insights

Area: Lively historic quarter near Santa Croce, popular with students and tourists; nightlife and pubs cluster along narrow streets.

Safety: Busy, well-trafficked nightlife area; crowding late nights with mixed reports about aggressive behavior and bouncer issues.

Nearby: Steps from Basilica di Santa Croce; surrounded by bars, casual eateries, and student hangouts; easy walk from central sights.

Santa CroceSanta Croce is a lively neighborhood centered around the famous Basilica of Santa Croce, blending historic charm with a vibrant dining and nightlife scene. It attracts a mix of tourists exploring Florence's cultural heritage and locals enjoying traditional and contemporary Tuscan cuisine in a casual, social atmosphere.

nullnull

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday16:00–04:00 Tuesday16:00–04:00 Wednesday16:00–04:00 Thursday16:00–04:00 Friday11:30–04:00 Saturday11:30–04:00 Sunday11:30–04:00

Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout

View full analysis on Seemor →