Seemor

Pizzarito NY Pizza By The SliceBWorth Trying

Name: Pizzarito NY Pizza By The Slice
Address: 4371 Glencoe Ave Ste B-7, Marina Del Rey, CA 90292, Marina Del Rey, United States
Rating: 4.8

4371 Glencoe Ave Ste B-7, Marina Del Rey, CA 90292 · Pizza restaurant, Italian restaurant, Pizza delivery · 4.8/5 Google (968 reviews)

Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Classic NY-style slices with lots of local love, counter-service ease, and cash-only quirks; go for thin-crust cheese, Sicilian, or pinwheels if you like a crisp reheat.

Why it gets a B for overall quality

Pizzarito NY Pizza delivers solid neighborhood slice-shop quality with above-average food quality anchored by crisp, foldable NY-style pies and beloved garlic knots that keep regulars returning. Strong service attentiveness and quick reheat times support the casual counter-service experience, though inconsistent execution and basic ambiance prevent grade A territory. For authentic NY slice cravings in a no-frills setting, it delivers reliable satisfaction.

Restaurant Summary

The room reads like a classic slice joint: pies in the case, a steady flow of locals and travelers, and staff who keep things moving. One diner summed it up as warm and bustling with crisp, quick-heated slices that scratch the NY itch. Expect friendly counter banter, though a few guests have found interactions brusque at times. The cooking is straight-ahead NY-style: thin, foldable pies, square Sicilian, and old-school sides like garlic knots, stromboli, and pinwheels. When the reheat is spot-on, the crust stays crisp with a balanced sauce-cheese pull; regulars rave, while a few NY purists call the sauce sweet or the texture too soft. If you want classic comfort over culinary fireworks, this is your slice stop. Families fare well here. Kids latch onto cheese and pepperoni slices, and there are gentle options like garlic knots, plain Sicilian, and chicken parm sandwiches. No vegan pizza options are evident, but vegetarians will find cheese pies, ricotta-spinach combos, and salads that keep choices straightforward for younger palates.

At a Glance

Crisp NY-style slices and nostalgic Sicilian win repeat fans
Garlic knots with marinara are a crowd favorite
Cash-only in-store; card via online ordering with reported minimums
Polarized views from NY purists on sauce and crust
Large gourmet pies are pricey relative to slices

What Sets It Apart

classic_ny_slice_case
longstanding_local_following
sicilian_and_pinwheels

What People Love

That first hot, foldable bite
Old-school vibe and friendly counter energy
Garlic knots with bright marinara
Reliable, fast reheat for lunch rush
Sicilian that reminds some of home

Points of Concern

Cash-only for in-person orders; several note ATM fees and online order minimums
A minority report sweet sauce or doughy texture not matching NY expectations
Service can feel brusque when busy; defensive owner replies reported
Pricing on large gourmet pies ($37) feels high versus slice value

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleCounter With Seating Average Cost$20-32 per person ReservationsNot required

What to Order

Start with a cheese slice to gauge the crust and sauce balance
Pair slices with garlic knots for a satisfying light meal under $15
Sharing? Consider one large gourmet pie and a salad to round it out

Perfect For

Quick slice before the marina or airport
Casual family night with pizza and knots
Nostalgic NY-style cravings
Solo counter meal on the go

Location Insights

Area: Waterside, mixed residential and office hub popular with locals and visitors; casual dining and marina foot traffic.

Safety: Generally safe, well-lit commercial center with steady foot traffic typical of Marina del Rey.

Nearby: Near marina promenades, offices, and retail; convenient for quick meals before airport runs or beach visits.

Marina Del ReyThe dining scene in Marina Del Rey is casual to upscale with a strong emphasis on seafood and waterfront dining, alongside diverse international options. The atmosphere is laid-back and often caters to visitors and locals enjoying the marina and beach lifestyle.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday10:30–23:00 Tuesday10:30–23:00 Wednesday10:30–23:00 Thursday10:30–23:00 Friday10:30–01:00 Saturday10:30–01:00 Sunday10:30–23:00

Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →