Creative New American cooking with standout tasting menus and excellent service; pricey, occasionally inconsistent, and limited for vegan diners.
Puritan & Company delivers exceptional food quality anchored by a celebrated tasting menu and strong pastry program, paired with outstanding service attentiveness and knowledgeable wine guidance. However, inconsistent execution—occasional seasoning and temperature issues—prevents the grade A territory this kitchen reaches on its best nights. The warm neighborhood setting and loyal following position it as a competitive choice among Boston's better dining destinations, though it lacks the consistency or distinctive identity to rank among the region's finest.
One caveat: Occasional inconsistency in seasoning and serving temperature