Small slice shop with friendly service, very low prices, and broadly liked pies; a few critics cite bland pies and cramped space.
Madison Street Pizza earns its grade through reliable crispy crust and fresh slices paired with exceptional friendliness and quick service. Outstanding value with specials like 2 slices for $5 makes it competitive with the area's better neighborhood pizza spots. However, very limited seating and cramped quarters plus occasional reports of bland flavor prevent grade A territory—this is grab-and-go comfort pizza, not destination dining.
One caveat: Space is very small; expect takeout or quick turnover seating