Delivery · Takeout
Casual Midtown Mexican spot with all-day $5 margaritas, lively vibes, and solid crowd-pleasers; food quality and service can be inconsistent, and an automatic 18% service charge appears on some checks.
Maiz delivers solid casual Mexican-American dining with friendly, attentive service and exceptional value ($5 margaritas), but inconsistent food execution—ranging from flavorful carne asada to dry meats and rice-heavy portions—prevents a higher grade. The convenient Midtown location and lively atmosphere make it a reliable pre-theater stop, though isolated food safety concerns warrant caution and monitoring.
The room feels warm and bustling with music and a steady stream of $5 margaritas that draw a mixed Midtown crowd. Service is often friendly and quick, with servers called out by name, though a few tables report lapses like missed drinks. Some checks include an automatic service charge, and a handful of diners mention upset stomachs, so expectations should be casual and value-driven rather than refined. The kitchen leans classic Mexican-American comfort: tacos, fajitas, enchiladas, and hefty quesadillas. Carne asada shines when it is on form, and churros bites and street corn get love. The culinary approach feels straightforward and familiar: flavor-first crowd-pleasers instead of chefly experiments. If you want a lively stop with inexpensive drinks and solid staples, this is great for pre-theater and group meetups. Families will find kid-friendly options like cheese quesadillas, chicken tacos, and churros on the current menu. Portions skew generous, but a few reviewers note rice-heavy fillings or dry meats, so pick simple items for picky eaters. There is no dedicated kids menu, but the basics (chips, rice and beans, flan) make it easy for younger palates.
Area: Busy Midtown West corridor near Times Square with heavy foot traffic and mixed tourist-office crowd.
Safety: Well-lit, high foot traffic; typical Midtown bustle with generally safe, crowded sidewalks.
Nearby: Near Times Square theaters, hotels, Port Authority, and many quick-serve eateries and bars.
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →