Seemor
ShalelB-Mixed Bag
65 W 70th St, New York, NY 10023
· Mediterranean restaurant, Bar, Cocktail bar
· 4.5/5 Google (699 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Moody, romantic Mediterranean hideaway with strong drinks and atmospheric charm; good food with highlights, but inconsistent service and premium pricing—go for the vibe, order selectively.
Why it gets a B- for overall quality
Shalel's exceptional subterranean design and strong service attentiveness create a genuinely romantic destination, but documented food safety incidents and inconsistent food quality across visits introduce legitimate concerns. The restaurant excels at mood and cocktails but falters on execution reliability—a problematic combination when safety is involved.
Restaurant Summary
Descending the stairs feels like slipping into another world—stone arches, candles, and a hush that makes conversations feel conspiratorial. Guests describe romantic nooks and a cave-like glow, with servers who, at their best, feel attentive and personal. One diner put it simply: "Most romantic spot in the neighborhood." Do note that a handful found service inconsistent at peak times. The kitchen leans elevated traditional across the Mediterranean—Moroccan tagines, Greek pastries, Italian pastas—so the culinary approach is regional and comfort-forward rather than experimental. Highlights include lamb dishes, mezze, and baklava; premium apps like octopus divide opinion on value. Cocktails and NA options earn praise, and this is a spot where you are paying for ambiance and location as much as the plate. Families can make it work thanks to flatbreads and pastas, grilled chicken or steak kebabs, and simple sides. The room is very dim and date-focused, so younger kids may be less at ease. Gluten-free swaps (like cucumbers for pita) and several vegetarian/vegan choices are available, but confirm substitutions and charges before ordering.
At a Glance
- Dramatically romantic subterranean setting with candlelit nooks
- Strong cocktails and accommodating NA drinks
- Broad Mediterranean menu with reliable lamb and desserts
- Premium prices for small appetizers; value varies
- Service inconsistency and occasional management friction
What Sets It Apart
- subterranean_romantic_nooks
- broad_mediterranean_menu
- cocktail_program
What People Love
- The hidden, candlelit cave atmosphere
- Attentive servers who guide choices
- Flavorful lamb dishes and mezze spreads
- Pistachio baklava that ends on a high note
Points of Concern
- Pricing feels high on appetizers like mezze and octopus
- Service swings from exceptional to dismissive depending on night
- Very dim lighting; some find seating cramped or worn
- Isolated but serious safety complaints (glass shards) and one food poisoning report—management follow-up mixed
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$65-90 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Pair one hot mezze ($18-22) with a hearty main ($33-39) to balance value
- Vegetarian diners: consider Wild Mushroom Risotto ($29) or Vegetarian Moussaka ($33)
- Seafood fans: Whole Branzino ($42) or Grilled Salmon Dolmas ($38); confirm doneness preference
Perfect For
- Date nights where mood matters most
- Pre- or post-Lincoln Center dinners
- Cocktail-and-mezze grazing
- Small celebrations in a cozy nook
Location Insights
Area: Residential-upper tier UWS near Lincoln Center; date-night and pre-show crowd, cozy side-street setting.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked; interior is subterranean and dim, with stairs reported wet on one occasion.
Nearby: Near Lincoln Center, Central Park West, Columbus Ave bars; convenient for performances and strolls.
Upper West SideThe Upper West Side boasts a diverse dining scene ranging from high-end restaurants to cozy neighborhood bistros. It is characterized by a relaxed yet sophisticated social atmosphere, attracting locals and visitors who appreciate quality food and a community-oriented environment.
Lincoln SquareLincoln Square is known for its cultural landmarks like Lincoln Center, drawing a crowd interested in performing arts and upscale dining. The area features a mix of elegant restaurants and casual spots catering to both pre-show dinners and everyday dining.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday16:30–23:00
Tuesday16:30–23:00
Wednesday16:30–23:00
Thursday16:30–00:00
Friday16:30–00:00
Saturday16:30–00:00
Sunday16:30–23:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →